Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• GT

  Gordon Trynor

  4 days ago
  1.0
  Two years ago I gave this place 5 stars and the owner jeff said to comeback for more. We have beenback several times in the past 2 years(at least 12 plus times but after today I probably won't be back. Today I'm giving them a 1 and can honestly say this is some of the worst pizza I've ever had. My order was supposed to be done around 501. At 518 they bring me a pizza with under cooked crust, I ordered crispy crust. I sent it back and finally left(around 525) with a pie that had crispy crust. Little did I know the pie was going to taste and look like cardboard with cheese and sauce. Having ordered using the app I couldn't just say cancel my order and I'll go somewhere else. Johnys needs to remember there are other pizza places out there and Fratellis in grayson isn't that much more of a drive.
• JT

  Just the Truth

  Feb 11, 2026
  4.0
  It seems like a great pizza in the area is hard to find. This pizza was good and it was a "take out" order. The place said on the phone that is would be about 35 minutes. Got there about 20 minutes later and it was pretty busy, but waited about 5 minutes just to talk to the cashier. The pizza was already done and sitting there waiting? Ordered 2 pies and the flavor was good, just had a little underwhelming kind of experience with the service and the pizza. This was the first time I had tried Johnny's and I am still on the search for the "go to" pizza joint!
• MB

  Marta Bornowska

  Feb 7, 2026
  5.0
  First time here. Out of town. It's been a while since I've been to Johnny's. Had no idea they did more than pizza and calzones! We had the BBQ chicken pizza Margherita Flat Bread Chicken Philly (best chk philly I've ever had) The bar is nice, the staff are friendly. 10/10
• BT

  B. Taylor

  Jan 6, 2026
  5.0
  Just an all around great place to eat. Food was delicious, woman over the phone and at the counter was very nice and helpful, and it is not over-priced.Will definitely be back!
• AH

  A H

  Dec 27, 2025
  2.0
  I accidently ordered from this location, instead of our usual locations in Grayson and Lawrenceville. My fault. I Understand how different locations have different menus but we always get the bronx bomber dinner meal. Has always came with and baked on top of spaghetti noodles. This location does not make it that way. No big deal, it's my fault for not looking. However, what we received isn't even how it is described in the menu. No sauce and no cheese baked on top. This was a sorry dish of dry meatballs, no sauce, maybe a chunk of tomato I would say, with a few pepperoni and peppers for garbish. Chefs should make sure their items are not only how the menu states, but presentable as well. Calzones ordered were not near as big as before, but they were okay, and Chicken Alfredo was dry, no sauce hardly, but son thought it was okay anyways. Not only did I drive half an hour out of my way, for this, but spent the money for it as well. I learned my lesson.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza