Customers frequently praised the pizza for its delicious taste, fresh ingredients, and authentic New York style.
Service
The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, welcoming, and attentive, contributing to a positive dining experience.
Atmosphere
Many reviews highlighted the inviting and comfortable atmosphere of the restaurant, making it a pleasant place to dine.
Inconsistencies
Some customers reported issues with order accuracy and food preparation, indicating a need for improvement in consistency.
JL
jonny louis
Jan 6, 2026
5.0
The guy was amazing and super friendly! He was great with everyone I saw him interact with! Pizza was great as well! 10 outta 10 for sure
DM
David M. McCulloch
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
I grabbed a large Neapolitan from this spot today! Excellent pizza, service, and the staff was warm and inviting. Loved it. Devoured it before I could post a pic. Cheers everyone.
DW
Darci Wells
Dec 23, 2025
1.0
We arrived at 8:04 pm, well before the posted 9:00 pm closing time on Google and on the door. The restaurant was empty except for one person waiting on a to-go order.
As soon as my mother and I walked in, four employees at the counter turned and stared at us. A man asked if we were dining in or to-go. When I said dine in, he looked at a clock and said, “You have 30 minutes. No, 26 minutes to eat and go. We close dining at 8:30.” When we started to just leave, he waved toward the dining room and said, “You now have 25 minutes.”
When the waitress came over, I asked if we would have enough time if we ordered right away. Her response was, “Well, what do you want?” When I said salad and pizza, she told us to order a mini pizza because it cooks faster.
At that point, it was clear we were not welcome. I told her I didn’t feel like they wanted us there, and her response was simply, “Yeah.”
I haven’t dined in for about six months since moving across town, but I regularly order delivery for work, usually serving 10-15.
I completely understand giving customers a heads-up when they arrive within the last 15–20 minutes of closing. That said, nearly an hour before posted closing time felt unnecessary and unwelcoming. If the dining room closes at 8:30, that should be clearly communicated. I hope management takes a look at how this situation was handled, as it cost them a loyal customer.
AF
Ashley Fromm
Dec 23, 2025
3.0
Super friendly staff but when you pay $23 for a medium pizza it would be nice if #1 the pizza was cut all the way through and #2 if after waiting 10 minutes before you even try to pick up a slice, it would be great if all of the cheese and toppings didn't slide right off! Waste of good money!
TJ
Toya Jordan
Dec 23, 2025
5.0
I wish that would have taken pictures but we tore into it as soon as I put the boxes on the table. The grandma's pie is by far the best pizza I have had out of all the places I've visited across the country from Callifornia to Maine, no exaggeration! They use very fresh ingredients and you can tell they treat the pizza like art, carefully placing each vegetable and/or meat. Every time that I come in to pick up my order, the owner is as authentic as his food. If you have not tried Grandma's N.Y. Pizza, you are missing out!
Frequently Asked Questions About Grandma's N.Y. Pizza
What are the general opening hours of Grandma's N.Y. Pizza?
Grandma's N.Y. Pizza is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Does Grandma's N.Y. Pizza offer delivery and in-store pickup services?
Yes, they offer both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What are the takeout hours for Grandma's N.Y. Pizza?
Takeout is available from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Where is Grandma's N.Y. Pizza located?
It is located at 911 Duluth Hwy 120 Suite E3, Lawrenceville, GA 30043, USA.
What types of cuisine and categories does Grandma's N.Y. Pizza offer?
They offer pizza, Italian cuisine, pasta, sandwiches, seafood, salads, vegetarian options, desserts, family dining, and catering services.
How can I view the menu or place an order online for Grandma's N.Y. Pizza?
You can view the menu and place orders online by visiting https://grandmasnypizza.com/menu.
What is the phone number to contact Grandma's N.Y. Pizza?
You can contact them at +1 770-995-5200.
Are there other pizza restaurants or eateries near Grandma's N.Y. Pizza?
Yes, nearby dining options include Newk's Eatery, The Captain's Boil for seafood, Happy China for Chinese cuisine, and LongHorn Steakhouse for American-style dining.
What nearby services or shops could be convenient for customers visiting Grandma's N.Y. Pizza?
Customers can access nearby services such as Publix Super Market at Merton Walk for groceries, Gwinnett Dental Care for dental services, and Kay's Salon for beauty and hair treatments.
Are there local transportation or community spots near Grandma's N.Y. Pizza that customers could explore?
Yes, nearby places include UPS Authorized Shipping Outlet for courier services, Lawrenceville Kiwanis Club for community events, and Redbox for video and game rentals, all conveniently located near Grandma's N.Y. Pizza.