Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• JM

  John McClure

  Mar 7, 2026
  2.0
  Pizza was not bad but not what I was expecting. Service was non existent. Server took our order, then dropped off our drinks and never came back until we had to ask another server for the check.
• JD

  Jeffrey Davis

  Mar 1, 2026
  2.0
  I’ve tried this place at least 5 times, so I hereby given the benefit of the doubt. Maybe if you order at the restaurant, the pizza isn’t served to you with a pool of grease sloshing around the center of the pizza like a hot tub. The garlic knots felt like burnt crisps doused in ungodly amounts of oil. I’m surprised I didn’t become see-through myself after eating anything from there. I feel bad because I’m sure there are people that value their work that work at this location, but maybe I’ve just learned that Johnny’s will never be for me
• TS

  Todd Sabat

  Feb 20, 2026
  1.0
  Said to post this cause I did love their pizza but after the almost hour wait for a med pizza when the place had 10 people in it, then when I canceled my food paid the $8 for my drinks and left the girls just chuckled Well they lost a local customer and one who will tell all my customers not to go here anymore. Capoes to the rescue and now me and my family’s new go to
• DS

  DD S

  Jan 7, 2026
  1.0
  This was my 2nd time trying this store out. The first time was really nice, but for some reason the experience wasn't the same today. I ordered the lunch special for the 2nd time. Today it seemed like old pizza that sat out to long and was just reheated or something. Took about 8 to 10 min. NOT HAPPY😤😠 About 12 bucks, (a tip included) for dry pep pizza...😡 NOT HAPPY! Oh, the service was ok....I said ok....not bad just ok. Yep, maybe a different location for sure. Lunch is time, time is money and money is too hard to earn to be paying out for crap items, service or food. Right America!!!
• AG

  Amanda K. Gatlin

  Dec 21, 2025
  4.0
  The food was good and consistent with the other Johnny's locations I've frequented. The server was very pleasant. She was the only server on duty, and there was only one other person working, the cook. This was during lunch hour, so it took a while to get our food. I have enjoyed eating at various Johnny's locations over the years, and the food has always been consistently good. I would definitely go back to this location again.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza