Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• DS

  Damion S

  6 days ago
  1.0
  This was my 2nd time trying this store out. The first time was really nice, but for some reason the experience wasn't the same today. I ordered the lunch special for the 2nd time. Today it seemed like old pizza that sat out to long and was just reheated or something. Took about 8 to 10 min. NOT HAPPY😤😠 About 12 bucks, (a tip included) for dry pep pizza...😡 NOT HAPPY! Oh, the service was ok....I said ok....not bad just ok. Yep, maybe a different location for sure. Lunch is time, time is money and money is too hard to earn to be paying out for crap items, service or food. Right America!!!
• AG

  Amanda K. Gatlin

  Dec 21, 2025
  4.0
  The food was good and consistent with the other Johnny's locations I've frequented. The server was very pleasant. She was the only server on duty, and there was only one other person working, the cook. This was during lunch hour, so it took a while to get our food. I have enjoyed eating at various Johnny's locations over the years, and the food has always been consistently good. I would definitely go back to this location again.
• DD

  Danimal

  Dec 15, 2025
  2.0
  Been going for 10 years the main cook moved to the Canton store; the new cooks don't know how to make pizza. Cold garlic knots and burned cheese and pepperoni pizza. Turn the oven temp down and use better quality cheese.
• JS

  Javion Stephens

  Dec 11, 2025
  5.0
  The owners are funny and they have great service its always on time hot and ready. I get new things every time I go its always good and yea it might be expensive but its some DAMM good food. So thankyou for the good service and food.
• TM

  THOMAS MACDONALD

  Dec 4, 2025
  1.0
  My wife and I were driving back home through Atlanta and decided to call in for a pizza to pick up. After calling for 20 minutes and getting a busy signal , I finally arrived and asked the young man if their phones were not working. He just started laughing and pointed to a female employee on the business phone and said " Talk to her she's been on the phone all night ". He took my order and my wife and I had to sit in the car and wait for almost 30 minutes. When I went back in for the pizza it just came out of the oven and the young man put it on the counter and didn't say one word. This happened the night before Thanksgiving and I left a detailed message with the Manager of the Carrolton location ( He apparently owns the Kennesaw store ) and he obviously doesn't care about his customers has yet to return my call in 7 days. Pizza was not good and the cooks looked like they were homeless. I guess i wont be getting a call from the owner who wont even hire a manager for the Kennesaw store ( Hence the terrible service ) They will only leave you the same AI Generated BS reply they leave for everyone . STAY AWAY FROM THIS PLACE TOO MANY OTHER AWESOME PIZZA PLACES AROUND! Why does the reply from Johnny's say its from the owner and its really from a guy at corporate named Jeff????? Again, The owner obviously does not care, I left a detailed message with a female manager at the Carrolton location.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza