Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• AD

  Andrew Dempsey

  4 days ago
  3.0
  I ordered online this evening and the wait was 50 minutes. Once I arrived I heard others had been waiting for an hour. It’s a Friday night and not a ton of dining options in the area so the wait was to be expected and staff was very polite and attentive. I did get home finally and found that the garlic knots were wayy over cooked and some were burned. I understand a little over cooked but this is not something that should’ve been packaged up and sent out the door. Not impressed with this order tonight but overall the staff is great and the environment is wonderful. Pizza was worth the wait.
• JS

  Joshua Sandvig

  4 days ago
  3.0
  Food is just meh. Thier sauce is very sweet. The meatballs had no flavor or seasoning whatsoever. Service was good and the atmosphere was what you would expect for a pizza joint.
• MS

  Mary Spring

  Apr 20, 2026
  5.0
  We come for the food; we stay for the music, atmosphere and friendly service. I highly recommend the wings. My husband says the pizza is the best he's ever had and the kids swear by the garlic knots!
• GV

  Gladytza Vazquez

  Apr 8, 2026
  5.0
  Our server Robert was very attentive, friendly and refilled our drinks without us even asking. He even went to the extent & brought us a to go box without us even asking. Great service, honestly. He also made sure our table was cleared before the food arrived. The look of the place looks clean, well taken care of & the pizza was delicious. I’ve never had pizza where the bread stayed crispy the entire time (usually soggy). Will definitely be making another visit soon.
• CH

  CA Hyde

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  Ordered our pizza for pick up over the phone, I guess you can also do it on their website. Went to pick it up. It was my first time finding the location and FYI, the parking lot entrance/exit are one way - a little confusing and inconvenient. The parking lot at 6:30 on a Friday was packed, luckily I found a spot along the edge of the pavement to pull into. Pizza was ready in time. We got sausage, mushroom and green pepper. Plenty of veggies, and fresh mushrooms, not canned! The Italian sausage was a little scarce on the pie, couldn't taste too much of it. Overall the pizza was good, the large is a good size and the crust was correct for a NY pie. The dining room gets loud and crowded, so I would prefer to take home. I would definitely order from here again.