Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• SJ

  Shannon Jackson

  Dec 29, 2025
  1.0
  Ordered BBQ pizza and Cheese deal and the pizza was old and hard horrible experience. When calling to speak to a manager I was put on hold
• MS

  Monique Shepard

  Dec 20, 2025
  3.0
  When I picked up order the cashier wasn't very nice. Combo pizza very salty. Mediterranean salad a bunch of lettuce and red onion, olives very salty.
• TT

  Trivell Thomas

  Dec 20, 2025
  5.0
  Great food and really good service. The atmosphere is very local-friendly with a bar and TVs throughout it. I'd definitely recommend this establishment.
• MS

  Maliyah Solomon

  Dec 13, 2025
  1.0
  I was a consistent customer through door dash, I ordered from this restaurant at least 2 to 3 times a week. When I first started ordering from the restaurant I was trying something new every time I placed a order on DoorDash and couldn’t find any thing that was close to good, there pasta is very bland and lacks flavor, the one slice pizzas are premade and when I ordered the one slice of pizza with extra sauce, I received a plan cheese pizza with tomato sauce added on the top of the pizza warmed up🙄, I was at my wits end but I decided to give the restaurant one more try and I tried their 10 piece wings which I surprisingly like but the price for them is outrageous and they don’t even come with a side or drink but I continued to order them because it’s hard to find a place that cooks wings correctly. Long story short i order through DoorDash every day and I order from this restaurant at least 2-3 times a week. Ive had my DoorDash account for a longggg time and there are some dashers that I have blocked from picking up my orders because the dashers mistreat or mishandle my food and I’ve also called the store prior to dasher picking up my food and my food was still handed to the wrong dasher, Due to these errors I have had to cancel orders from this store, today I placed my order as normal and called to see if they could fry my wings a little bit longer as I normally do with this store and not even 1 - 2 minutes later after I got off the phone with the store my order was cancelled. I immediately called to see why my order was canceled and i was informed that the owner wanted to block me from ordering because of previous canceled orders. So instead of taking this issue up with DoorDash or calling me back to see why orders were canceled I was blocked from ordering at the store. I spent close to $30 - $50 on every order. They obviously do not value their consistent customers, The customer service their is absolutely trash I found my self having to be overly nice to the staff because they were always rushing you, snippy, and rude but I had to be overly nice I felt so my food would be done correctly. I’m kind of glad they canceled my order because I found a hidden gem closer to my house that is more affordable and has the same exact items plus more variety in their menu and most of all taste better and has more seasoning in the food. Again i do not recommend this restaurant they are very over priced, food is bland, terrible customer service, and they do not value their consistent paying customers.
• SH

  Shaun Hann

  Dec 2, 2025
  2.0
  I love Johnny's pizza in Atlanta off of Chesire bridge and to find out I had 1 near my residence, I couldn't wait to try it. I was very much let down. it's like I ate at a totally different restaurant. Pizza tasted like yesterday's cardboard. The wings were gross and undercooked. The only things that were reasonable was the cheesecake and the Caesar salad, but the dressing was a little bit off. Never eating at this location again.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza