GoodFellas Pizza & Wings Avondale

Reviews

• ES

  Emma Shippee

  Nov 6, 2025
  3.0
  These are the smallest wings I have ever seen! Like comically small lol. Like chick wings, not chicken. I think they knew though because they did give 2 extra wings. The lemon pepper flavor itself was great though. The pizza was pretty basic, but did have an adequate amount of toppings
• FB

  favor blessed

  Nov 4, 2025
  1.0
  I stopped by support this new business in the area. They didn’t have any takeout menus. The menu displayed on the board didn’t show the toppings/ ingredients for the specialty pizzas. It only showed the names. I ordered a large house pizza ($18). The pizza was ready fast. The dough was soft and not cooked all the way through. The pizza sauce was bland. The pizza had no flavor. I love NY style pizza, but Goodfellas was a HUGE disappointment. Lil Caesar’s tastes better. Frozen pizza even tastes better. They deserve 0 stars!
• CJ

  Candace Jackson

  Oct 30, 2025
  5.0
  Here’s a polished version of your review you can post online: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Goodfellas Pizzeria Review Goodfellas Pizzeria is a true gem..(I ate there 4 days straight)— a Black-owned establishment serving up great food and even better vibes! The wings were perfectly seasoned and cooked just right, and the fries were crispy and fresh with every bite. The pizza was fulfilling, flavorful, and made with care. You can really taste the quality in every dish. Highly recommend if you’re looking for good food and great service all in one spot! 🍕🍗🍟
• FG

  Flame Gardner

  Oct 14, 2025
  4.0
  I hate to see all the terrible reviews about this place 😕. I don't know what kind of experiences they're having to give it 1 star, but I can definitely agree that certain elements of the business could be much better. My experience was cool. I'm glad there's a place in the area that stays open til Midnight and even later on the Fri & Sat... bonus points for that alone. Also, I do not know what the pizza tastes like because that is not something that I eat on a regular. No no beef and not much dairy so the frozen pizza taste you all are complaining about is beyond me but from what I see those pies come out of a real pizza oven. I had some lemon pepper wings aznd they were FFIIIRRREE 🔥🔥🔥. Cooked to perfection 👌🏾👌🏾👌🏾. Best wings I've had on this side of town... they just dethroned my current champs. I don't know if it's because it was slow that night so they had time to pay attention to my food but they were absolutely perfect. I will be returning to verify if they are indeed as good as the first time (great blue cheese too). This spot has a lot of potential... great space... great location. There are a few things in the way, though. First and foremost is CUSTOMER SERVICE. Now while I didn't experience "bad" customer service; it was definitely DRY. Nonchalant employees are bad for business. I have only ever seen black men behind the counter which leads me to believe that it is a black-owned business ran by men but I want my brothers to remember that being a boss does not mean that you don't have to be nice to the very patrons and people who are sustaining life for you as a business owner. I think a lot of us view being nice at a job as a lower level thing and something that only a worker or in an African-American mindset case a slave it's supposed to do. You should take pride in your business and greet your customers as if you want them to have the best experience they've ever had at a restaurant and not just as a means of monetary gain. Get your script together... "Hello welcome to Goodfellas y'all come in and have a good time order what you want"... SOMETHING, but don't just look at people expecting them to speak to you first when you are in the business of service. Make your employees recite the script to customers as they come and if the employees don't want to do it fire them and find people who are willing to go above and beyond because what makes them look good makes the business looks good and everybody's trying to level up. A bad day for a business owner does not mean that you allow yourself to stoop to the level of certain customers and match energies with them you are always supposed to be stoic. The demeanor and energy in which you choose to handle your customers is what will resonate most throughout the community, and the fact that you all have so many complaints about unprofessionalism when it comes to dealing with customers is a serious issue. Furthermore, your aesthetics are decent but they aren't doing anything to keep customers captivated. This restaurant is set up in a bar style. You would think they had alcoholic beverages there. But I noticed that the two TVs are not cohesive with what energy you want inside of your place. One TV is on multiple four-way screen what's a bunch of sports commentary and no real sports. The other TV is on a movie streaming app. Nobody comes to a bar themed place to see you watch Netflix movies. Both TVs should be on two different sports at all times you also need a third TV to leave it on the news and a TV outside to play an additional game on your patio area. Please do better. You're sitting on a gold mine if you play it right. I will be returning. Final analysis next visit.
• KK

  Kenya Kardashian

  Oct 11, 2025
  5.0
  I stopped by after walking Stone Mountain and I really enjoyed the vibe. I had the Jerk Chicken pizza and wings. I was able to enjoy a few slices inside but the wings were so good, I had to order an extra 10pc to go. The pizza was fresh & hot & hit the spot. I'm definitely dropping by again.

Frequently Asked Questions About GoodFellas Pizza & Wings Avondale