AJ's Pizza Pub

Reviews

• KL

  Kevin Lomax

  Feb 20, 2026
  1.0
  The waitress was phenomenal. The kitchen however, was less than great. Two of us were finishing our meals while the other person never got their meal. We had to get it to go it took so long.
• AG

  Andrew Griffith

  Feb 19, 2026
  5.0
  My Sister in Law and I came and got some food recently and it was really good, high recommend the garlic knots, but our server set the bar and expectations for future visits. Our server’s name was Olivia, and she came and greeted us not only in a timely manner but with a great can do attitude. Throughout the meal she was very attentive and friendly and was even able to work with dietary restrictions! I hope my family and myself become regulars there because her service was amazing. And if she chooses to work for another company, they are lucky to have her! Good Job Olivia and keep up the fantastic work!!!!
• CG

  Charles Grubbs

  Feb 11, 2026
  3.0
  Enjoyed the meal but I informed the waitress that the temperature was cold and responded that they were running around and needed to keep cool. I felt like telling her that we are paying and you should try to keep your patrons comfortable. I guess it doesn’t matter.
• LB

  Larry Ballard

  Jan 12, 2026
  4.0
  AJ’s Pizza Pub has a welcoming vibe and a great atmosphere that makes you comfortable from the moment you walk in . There are comfortable booths and tables and a nice bar and plenty of friendly people enjoying food and drinks as well as serving them . If I had a pizza spot I’d want it to be very similar to this . We ordered the $29.99 special - a large pizza and 10 wings added on a $6 salad and two drinks . Somehow the bill totaled $50 . I’m not sure how the $6 salad and the two drinks added up to $20 , but it was a matter of a few dollars and not worth arguing about . The pizza , while probably the best in the area ( Cornelia, Clarkesville, Demorest and Baldwin… even Toccoa ) was unremarkable. The crust doesn’t seem to be fermented like traditional NY style is . The cold proofing of the dough usually results in a crust that is crisp and chewy with a tangy taste . This was just kind of bready , though the bottom was nice and crisp and cooked perfectly , and seemed to be stone or steel baked . There was very little sauce and most bites were just cheese bread . The pepperoni sat on top of the pizza , and seemed like it had been cooked on a pan and tossed on top of a cheese pizza . It was so unremarkable I didn’t even take a picture, I will include one here from my last visit , that I ordered with extra sauce ( it was better) . The wings, however, were exceptional ! Really , really good . Easily in the top 5 I’ve ever had . My wife eats wings EVERYWHERE . She orders them plain with sauce on the side . She’s very picky and states that these are among the best she’s ever eaten . A word of warning though, the hot buffalo is HOT!!! We had to ask for mild instead . It’s hot y’all. I don’t want this review to come off as bashing AJ’s it’s an awesome spot with a great atmosphere . The service was top notch , our waitress was great . We will definitely come back . Fun place with great people . If you’re a pizza snob , like me , the pizza may leave you a bit underwhelmed , but it’s still decent pizza and better than anything else in the region. The salad and wings were great and I’ll try something else next time . Worth a visit .
• KP

  Kevin Purcell

  Jan 10, 2026
  5.0
  Have to say. The sauces are one of kind original flavors. The Scorpion Death Lock is hotter than the Slow Burn at Taco Mac. His Scorpion sauce seems to be unique. It would be death hot for average person but nice burn for those of us they like the heat. I have not tasted this type hot sauce before. This place is very very unique. The Carolina Hot Sweet sauce reminds me of Colorado Coppers from Wild Wings. Also highly recommend the pizza. Never knew this place existed and only lived 15 minutes away. Will be returning soon.

Frequently Asked Questions About AJ's Pizza Pub