New York Butcher Shoppe & Wine Bar

Reviews

• JJ

  Jim Jordan

  Apr 9, 2026
  5.0
  Reading a lot about this place on columbus foodies. Been searching for a good Ruben sandwich, so gave it a try. $17 got me a toasted Ruben sandwich with fries and pickles. It was excellent. Our waitress was good, efficient and sweet. They toast the bread in a way that has its own flavor profile. The meat has a unique smokey flavor and they use real Russian dressing. The fries are well seasoned and make an great side. I'd highly recommend. Didn't take a picture, sorry.
• VK

  Von King

  Apr 4, 2026
  4.0
  Expensive cuts of meat but good variety. Dining area is smallish but a unique eating option.
• CC

  Capt Chaos83

  Apr 3, 2026
  5.0
  Great butcher shoppe and restaurant (neutral on the wine bar, I'm a non-drinker). Excellent service, excellent meals, would highly recommend!
• MR

  Mia Rankins

  Mar 29, 2026
  5.0
  It was my first time going and everyone was very helpful from the guy behind the meat section to everyone behind the bar and explained everything to me since it was my first time.They definitely pay close attention to their quality because everything was exceptionally fresh! My boyfriend and I ate there originally getting to go but everyone at the bar was very attentive. We had two giant ribeyes , we both have leftovers . I had the Brussel sprouts , he had the broccolini and we shared fries . We also had a slice of the blueberry cheesecake we shared. We spent $145 but we got the two steaks cooked and a side to go with it, fries, and a cheesecake and then I tipped $15 on my original to go order and then an additional $20 when we decided to eat there .In total we paid about $180 for everything ,but you have to pay for quality ! Will be back soon !
• AC

  Alys Caro

  Mar 15, 2026
  5.0
  We had our first visit and was in love. Our waiter was super informative over everything that was offered. It was a complete different experience for us in the way they offer your steaks and how they are cooked. The menu is super limited but everything sounded amazing. We started off with the meatball appetizer and it was delicious. The sauce was super creamy and the meatballs had the perfect kick of spice in it. Then the bread on the side was the perfect addition. I ordered the porkchop entree from the menu. The menu came with porkchop , brussel sprouts, and swet potato puree. Unfortunately they were out of the puree when we went so i subbed it out for the roasted potatoes. The potatoes were amazing however , i know that the puree wouldve been the perfect mix with the brussel sprouts. Im not a big veggie person and super picky when it comes to brussel sprouts. These were honestly the best brussel sprouts ive ever had!!! The candied pecans with goat cheese on them.. ahh CHEFS KISS. So so so so good. The wine was suggested by the waiter and it was the best amount of sweeet and smooth. We loved it ! And it was only $12.99! We will definitely be going back for more of those meatballs haha

Frequently Asked Questions About New York Butcher Shoppe & Wine Bar