New York Butcher Shoppe & Wine Bar

Reviews

• CC

  Chantelle

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Went here today with my coworkers and it was amazing! The food was delicious and the vibes were phenomenal. Keontaye behind the bar was amazing! He was attentive and super knowledgeable about the food and the atmosphere around. The smash burger was to die for! It was so juicy and flavorful. 1000/10 will be eating here again 🩷
• HB

  Heather Bennett-Simon

  Jan 4, 2026
  5.0
  Ate here with the family, to include a 9yr old and a 12 yr old. Did not feel unwelcomed but rather the opposite. Owner made rounds and genuinely connected with every table. Everyone loved their food. Family ordered the brisket grilled cheese sandwhich, the club sandwhich, the muffuletta, and the meatball sub. Was planning on being critical of brisket and the muffuletta - zero complaints. Texas and NOLA would both be proud. Excited to head back for grab and go meals on my lazy nights. Will be back with friends. Incredible addition to Columbus.
• SA

  Shelley Allison

  Jan 4, 2026
  5.0
  The atmosphere is quiet and classy. The coolers full of delicious treats. The meat that was for sale was bright, fresh and beat out the local grocery stores in pricing and cuts. My husband and I walked in with no pre-conceived notions of quality and were pleasantly surprised to find a Tuscan White Bean soup that was very well seasoned as well as a Smash burger that was anything but dry. David was awesome to talk to and he handled the crowds well. Anthony was very knowledgeable in meat selections and the different take home meals that were available. From individual servings all the way to family sizes, the take home meals were plentiful. We will be back and sooner rather than later.
• TT

  Tabitha

  Dec 27, 2025
  4.0
  First time here ... Heard they served lunch and dinner along with being a butcher shop. Had 2 waters, Reuben sandwich with rosemary and parmesan fries, NYB smash burger with fries also...$38. Food was really good!! Those fries are delicious and that Reuben was soooo good! Burger was good also, but I will just say the waitress did not ask how us how we wanted it cooked and it came well done. Waitress was very nice though! I can't wait to try their dinner one night and I hope they rotate the menu as they continue to do more business which I have no doubt they will do. The fresh meats are a bit pricey but seem to be great quality and we will be back to try some. They also have heat and eat prepped dishes like different Mac n cheese's, pasta, salads, beans, etc. They also have desserts like cheesecake and different chips, dry pastas, sauces, olives, crackers, oil, wine, etc. Wasn't busy at all when we went on a Saturday at 11:30am. Really like the low lighting, Frank Sinatra music, realaxed, mommas kitchen with a kick of classy vibe...lol. Certainly reminds me of places up North, but I'm glad they brought it to the South! We will definitely be back!!
• MO

  Maddie Olson

  Dec 23, 2025
  5.0
  I was blown away by this incredible addition to Columbus. Come one, come all, they have something for everyone. We stopped by to check out the meat selection to begin with, but were pleasantly surprised to find out it’s also a restaurant! Lunch and Dinner, so we came for both! Meat selection is incredible and sourced fresh. Plenty of options, cuts, flavors, if they don’t have what you want they will figure it out for you. Grocery selection varies from seasonings, snacks, pastas, jams, premade appetizers, and dinners for the family. Fresh meat including elk, venison, gulf shrimp, steak, sausage and prices are very reasonable. Wine selection, again something for all. I love a good red blend so I sampled the Levee & Loam. WOW it was so smooth. Reminded me of the Prisoner wine with a better bang for my buck! Went so well with dinner. They also do bottle to table, so if you purchase a bottle for dinner you can drink at your table, then take it home in a sealable bag. Lunch was divine, multiple selections… we did the smash burger with rosemary fries as well as the brisket grilled cheese…. SO much flavor! Dinner, let me tell you I will be a regular for this meal. The Waygu burger was orgasmic in the mouth. You are reading this laughing but wait till you try it… wild mushrooms, charred red onion, gruyere cheese, and truffle aioli atop a melt in your mouth burger. Smooth like butter baby. My husband tried the steak and Fritz which was also fantastic. Grilled teres major, with a chimichurri butter melted over it, it was to tender and cooked to perfection. Ginger was our server and I can’t say enough about her kindness and care to us! She was phenomenal. Please go out of your way to swing by here, thank me (&the chef & butcher of course) later

Frequently Asked Questions About New York Butcher Shoppe & Wine Bar