Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• RD

  Ruben Defaria

  Nov 15, 2025
  1.0
  Horrible Philly steak and cheese and Philly chicken steak subs. No nothing good l won't comeback anymore. Greek salad no taste.
• HW

  Holly White

  Nov 7, 2025
  2.0
  A little disappointed with this Johnny's considering I love the Johnny's in Cumming so much. The service was haphazard, and not attentive, and my pizza was undercooked and not cut. I had to go to the bar to ask someone to cut my pizza because my server vanished. Tables were left half cleaned. There seemed to be plenty of staff, so I'm not sure what the reasoning was. I think I will skip this location in the future.
• RS

  Ryan Steckbeck

  Nov 2, 2025
  2.0
  I will start by saying the fried ravioli is good. The price however is garbage. $7.99 for 5 fried ravioli is too steep. The pizza we got was wayyy too overdone. Bottom was crispy like a potato chip. All of the dough had big are pockets in them. The crust was almost burnt. Flavorless pizza and very subpar service. Took a good 6 minute for a server to come to us when it was “set yourself” and then we saw them 2 times. Once to take food order and second to bring us the food. Wasn’t checked on or anything. This location is NOT worth coming to. I’ll stick to the canton road in Marietta location. That one is always on point.
• JB

  Jeff Benn

  Oct 25, 2025
  5.0
  I changed my order to a large after placing it & they did it with no problem. Also they have veteran discount. 😊
• RN

  Review Name

  Oct 14, 2025
  1.0
  Edited Owner never contacted me. The cameras show what I described. Literally sitting in front of a stromboli and pasta covered with so much Parmesan it smelled like it needed monostat 7. I never touched either of the dishes nor the bread on the pasta plate. So despite asking about paying at cost for the restaurant, and being told no, EVEN THO MOST RESTAURANTS WILL JUST REMAKE THE FOD, the Johnny's pizza made a lifelong ban decision for us with their acts. People cannot afford this nonsense with economies as bad as now, and if this restaurant is in so much financial trouble as to make a decision like it made one would wonder why . . End edit They made me pay for food I cannot eat. I can't have certain Ingredients and did not see them on the menu and when I ordered the same thing from Two other Johnny's like That one In Suwanee not far away from here, parmesan cheese was not added to it. I assume it would all be the same. My bill not Including the drink was over Twenty Dollars. I would pay for my Dr pepper since I drank half of it but I should not have To pay for their food which I did not eat and I cannot Take with me to give To someone. The restaurant chain should be more clear about their Ingredients. People who practice different religions are better off not coming here. They would have scored higher If they had changed the cost To be at cost but would not. Jews Muslims Buddhists and a multitude of other religions who can't eat red meat beware. AT COST DOES NOT COST THE RESTAURANT ANYTHING . One other comment because Kelci F who was my server was aware that I would not eat certain Ingredients including meat because I told her that when I had her take the bacon off of my salad, she specifically said that she wasn't aware of my dietary restrictions and so there was no way to no to leave something off that was not vegetarian. LIKE I SAID, AT COST COSTS THE RESTAURANT NOTHING. I asked and she said no because her manager would not do it NO WONDER THEY HAVE S U C H LOW RATINGS HERE

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza