Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• IM

  Irina Marshalkin

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Good pizza. Great atmosphere. Can accommodate large groups.
• RS

  Randie Strom

  3 days ago
  5.0
  I’ve lived in Georgia for just over two years, and every day I’ve lived in Georgia I’ve been to Johnny’s (except when they’re closed). I like everything about Johnny’s, especially the staff—they are awesome. It’s unfortunate some patrons take advantage of their good nature and cause problems for others. For me, Johnny’s is a refuge and source of joy.
• MM

  Melissa Mann

  Mar 6, 2026
  1.0
  Want to love it but unless you love a jungle gym daycare on weekend nights- stay away. They cater to unsupervised groups of young children that run around like they should be at the gym. One child spit in front of our table. They were throwing these sticky balls way in the air all over right in front of our table/ zero care. It was nice outside / they could have gone out on the patio in order to not have been so rude to dining customers or here’s a real shocker- maybe teach kids how to behave inside a restaurant. Such an awful experience. It’s a bar for crying out loud.
• MS

  michael smith

  Mar 5, 2026
  5.0
  My neighborhood go to place!
• JE

  Jessica Lynn Elias

  Jan 29, 2026
  1.0
  First time ordering here and unfortunately the experience was disappointing. We placed a simple takeout order (two pepperoni pizzas, garlic bread, and lasagna). While waiting inside, we watched multiple customers who arrived after us receive their food and leave. After a long wait, the manager apologized and explained there was a kitchen mistake, offered a refund, and said our order would be ready in about 10 minutes. We appreciated the apology and understood that mistakes happen. However, we continued waiting and again watched other customers come and go. After 1 hour and 10 minutes, we approached the counter only to see our order being put together at that moment. That was extremely frustrating, especially after being told the issue had already been addressed. The lack of communication and follow-through made us feel overlooked and discriminated, which is disappointing—particularly for a first visit. While we appreciate the refund, the experience left a bad impression and makes it hard to return after being disrespected.