Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• BS

  Brianah Simon

  Jan 5, 2026
  1.0
  I’m from Jersey & obviously NY style pizza is a popular dish. This is no where near NY style pizza or at least not at this location. Dough wasn’t even all the way cooked , pepperoni undercooked and pizza sauce had no type of flavoring/seasoning. This is one of the top 2 worse pizzas I’ve ever had in my life and this was my celebratory meal for New Year’s Eve , way to end my 2025. I had to add my own seasonings to the pizza and recook it myself which as you can see looks way better 🤌. Price is affordable but for what I paid and what I tipped I’ve could’ve literally just made it myself for cheaper or got a frozen pizza. Young lady at the register who took my order was extremely sweet and welcoming. But I Wont be coming here again even if they were giving out pizza for free 🥴
• CL

  Cesar Castro (Happy life)

  Dec 11, 2025
  1.0
  I must say I love this restaurant but this location is far more worse then any I been too with my kids n wife ok we always come here but unfortunately are visit on Dec/10/2025 at 4pm was bad I held door open for cook no thank u push by us rush us to get out his way cool it didn’t say nothing server was ok till hair was found in my food my food was bought back out watery never eat pasta There again cook stood at window staring me down of course I’m Latino but hey all I got was racist energy every location we been to never had this issue we alway go for buffalo dip but we will no longer come here due to man wit long bob hair cut he rude mean n stealing at people with a angry face is soo uncomfortable even my 7 yr old daughter ask to leave leave cuz he didn’t stop staring
• KB

  Kimberly Boswell

  Dec 9, 2025
  2.0
  Johnny’s used to offer good pizza for a good price. It was always consistent and worth the price compared to the other pizza chains. But they aren’t anymore the price is higher and the quality is in the basement. Awful taste and skimpy toppings. They have officially lost me.
• JJ

  John Kent Fulton, Jr.

  Dec 7, 2025
  5.0
  Great people, great food, always quick and hot. Check 'em out and try some of their holiday beverages. Lizzy behind the bar is great!
• SS

  Simply

  Nov 30, 2025
  1.0
  I called in a slice of pizza and a cobb salad which I asked for extra red onion. The slice of pizza was thrown into a bare box, it was small, cold and appeared to have a piece torn off. The salad thrown together and was missing red onion. The cashier gave me a small black container with onion. I should have just asked for a refund. I will never revisit. This reminded me of a Fisher Price good pack for children.

Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza