Goodfellas Pizza & Wings

Reviews

• BL

  Bei Lu

  3 days ago
  5.0
  We ordered takeout pizza twice already. The pizzas were delicious. Authentic and you can tell that they use high quality ingredients. We love the cheese, sauce, and the toppings like sausages, pepperoni and beef. The crust is so good, we ate every bit of the crust. Normally, we leave the crusts from other pizza stores uneaten. We always order the largest size which gives you the best value. Plus, we love to heat up the leftovers for another meal. Definitely will order again.
• AC

  Ashley Clemons

  3 days ago
  1.0
  Oops I was just about to order from here again. But the reviews have me thinking twice. I will not be ordering from here again. The building looks rundown
• AW

  Andrea W

  Feb 19, 2026
  1.0
  The food is terrible, but the service is worse. The restaurant smelled of rotten eggs. Extremely rude staff and very poorly prepared food. I would not recommend and I would not return. The owners and management need to take a look at their staff. When attempting to simply share feedback with the kitchen (as we were told the cook is new) the waitress was rude to us and then proceeded to complain loudly from the kitchen so that the entire dining room could hear. If you aren’t interested in customer service, don’t work in a restaurant.
• GS

  Gabby Sturg

  Feb 12, 2026
  1.0
  Stay away from this pizza place. The owner thinks it’s ok to not provide an accurate order then have the audacity to ask you to come to the restaurant and pick up a corrected order after already paying DoorDash delivery fees. Only offering a discount for items that were inaccurate and will NOT be eaten. A full refund for services promised but not delivered is the only fix here. Then when speaking to an employee over the phone and letting them know that it is wrong to steal money from people like this I was hung up on. I ordered from the website itself which then directed me to DoorDash. I called DoorDash for support and then they also requested a refund from the store. Which DoorDash also stated they were not responsive. Spent almost $80 and this order was not eaten with the exception of a few pizza slices with were not good. Worst customer service I’ve ever experienced.
• AB

  austin basse

  Feb 7, 2026
  5.0
  Down in ATL from STL and MAN. Blown away. It was delicious. Did delivery and mozz sticks were still able to get that nice cheese pull. The pizza its self was top notch. Great crust layered perfectly with sauce, cheese and toppings. Full texture and flavor in each bite. Its pizza, sure, but when your from an area that is also big on pizza, it's nice to find a spot that makes a good slice. Now....throw some Provel on there and Woooooo. You're golden. Im going to tell the folks at The Hill back home about this place. 10/10