Osteria Olio

Reviews

• BS

  Brian Stambaugh

  2 days ago
  5.0
  We went here for dinner and had a lovely time. The focaccia with ricotta and honey was wonderfully balanced, and the cacio e pepe was perfectly done. The meatballs were good, and I would be hard pressed to say how they could have been better. The only problem we encountered was one of the bombolini in the basket was almost completely uncooked. I would absolutely recommend coming here for the amazing food.
• AP

  Amy PV

  Nov 9, 2025
  5.0
  This might be a 10-star experience... We were given a gift card and came to celebrate our anniversary. First, they many special touches to help us celebrate (I'll let it be a secret but we were very pleased). The ambiance is great. The food is sooo good. We got the $75/pp 3-Course Meal and it was the best food I've ever had (including cruise, resorts, fancy restaurants, etc). For the price, it's so great. We shared 2 appetizers, pizza, main, pasta, two veggie sides and two desserts. We will make this an annual tradition because it's so worth it. Made reservations two months in advance and highly recommend this ❤️
• LF

  Lauryn Factor

  Nov 4, 2025
  5.0
  Absolutely Amazing! Came here for a celebration dinner and I was blown away. I wanted to have a special evening and they definitely made us feel welcomed and catered to. Our server Bianca went over and beyond with her service. She was so attentive and very helpful when it came to pairing and menu selections. The overall staff and establishment was ran so smoothly and everyone was happy and polite, you can tell this place has great management. The food was spectacular very fresh. Presentation 10/10 if you want true authentic pasta you have came to the right place.
• MM

  Marsha

  Nov 2, 2025
  5.0
  What a gem! Out of the way and so beautiful! The staff is attentive but not intrusive. The food is perfect, delicious, seasoned just right. Enjoyed the polpete that had just a little spicy kick. Sunchokes and Brussels were beautifully cooked-portions were generous. Topped out off with the Torte de Pere... Chocolate with spiced Pear. Yummy cocktail that tasted like a cinnamon Christmas!! Can't wait to come back!
• ML

  Mike Lim

  Nov 1, 2025
  3.0
  I’ve been to Osteria Olio three times in the past six weeks — my daughter loves this place, and the food is always excellent. Unfortunately, the service on our most recent visit was so slow and disorganized that it really detracted from the experience. Our reservation was at 7:30 PM. My wife’s wine came promptly, but my mixed drink didn’t arrive until 7:50. Appetizers came out relatively quickly, but after that, our server disappeared for about 20 minutes — no check-in, no update on our mains, and empty glasses. When she finally came by, she mentioned she was just then putting in our entrée order — even though our appetizers had already been cleared at 8:15 and we’d said we were hungry. The mains didn’t arrive until 8:50, despite the dining room being only about half full. What made it worse was the lack of urgency or awareness. When I finally asked her to check on our order, she wandered to another table first, then to the kitchen, and never came back with an update until I flagged her down again. No apology, no acknowledgment of the delay. Don’t get me wrong — the food and ambiance are top-notch, and in past visits, the servers’ attentiveness made up for slower pacing. But this time, the lack of care from the staff really stood out and soured the evening. I’ll continue to recommend Osteria Olio for the food — just with a caveat that service can be painfully slow. For a restaurant with this reputation and this price point, it was just very disappointing.

Frequently Asked Questions About Osteria Olio