Business Details
About
Pizza RestaurantRestaurant Delivery ServiceTake Out RestaurantItalian Restaurant
Johnny’s Pizza Athens is proud to bring authentic, great-tasting New York Style Pizza and a variety of housemade dinners, craft beers, subs and more to the neighborhoods we call home. Our dough is made fresh daily, never frozen, hand-tossed and topped with the best ingredients we can find - premium mozzarella and parmesan cheeses, fresh-packed tomatoes, hand-cut veggies, and Italian sausage and beef with no fillers. Then each pizza is brick-oven baked until it’s golden brown, always with our signature soft and crispy crust, and served hot at your table. Dine-in or order online for takeout or delivery!
Visit us today at the intersection of Gaines School Rd. & Cedar Shoals Dr.
Details
- Dine-inAvailable
- DeliveryAvailable
- TakeoutAvailable
- Accepts reservationsNot available
Location
Johnny's New York Style Pizza
1040 Gaines School Road, Athens, GA
30605, United States
Hours
Reviews
4.3
847 reviews
5 stars
536
4 stars
165
3 stars
61
2 stars
32
1 star
53
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Mixed reviews on food quality; some praised the pizza and garlic knots, while others reported bland flavors and undercooked items.
Service Issues
Frequent complaints about slow service and staff miscommunication, with some positive mentions of friendly staff.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere received mixed feedback; some found it clean and welcoming, while others noted it felt dull and uninviting.
Pricing Concerns
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with pricing, feeling that the quality did not match the cost.
Consistency
Inconsistent experiences reported, with some customers noting a decline in quality and service over time.
- JDJoseph DuvallOct 28, 20254.0The food was pretty good, although the basic pizza place fare. The parking situation was a bit different for first timers, but not too bad.
- JJJimmy JordanOct 15, 20251.0Wait staff are not friendly, at all. We had a large party and instead of seating us in the large area, they insisted on putting 5-6 people at a 4 person table. The food is usually good. Use to be a good place to eat but things have changed and the people have change. Our party showed up and they had to sit all over the restaurant because the waitress didn’t want to put us together. The food took over an hour to get to us… some were finished and leaving when the others were just receiving their food. And, this was an event scheduled in advance.
- JCJuan CarlosOct 13, 20255.0I recommend that you go there. Excellent attention. Beautiful people to come and talk to. I recommend it.
- BTBlaine TottenSep 4, 20251.0Well I’m currently sitting on the toilet due to food poisoning. Pizza was beyond mid, and my chicken wings well…. I would consider taking them off the menu due to my state right now. AND how does one get the total of $40 from a small cheese pizza, 6 wings, garlic knots and 2 drinks. I can go to “Crust” in ALPHARETTA Ga, I can get muscles, appetizer, and my girlfriend a meal as well for $5 more. I mean it’s ridiculous. I think I’ll try my luck at a gas station with a blinking light next time.
- KBKathy BrownAug 25, 20255.0Always great food and service. Don't change anything!
Frequently Asked Questions About Johnny's New York Style Pizza
What type of pizza does Johnny's New York Style Pizza serve?
Johnny's New York Style Pizza serves authentic New York Style Pizza with hand-tossed dough, premium cheeses, fresh vegetables, and Italian sausage and beef without fillers, baked in a brick oven for a soft and crispy crust.
What are the opening hours of Johnny's New York Style Pizza?
Johnny's New York Style Pizza is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Does Johnny's New York Style Pizza offer dine-in and delivery options?
Yes, Johnny's New York Style Pizza offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery services to its customers.
Is Johnny's New York Style Pizza family-friendly and accessible?
Yes, Johnny's New York Style Pizza welcomes families, offers a children's menu, has high chairs, wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, and seating, including outdoor seating.
Does Johnny's New York Style Pizza serve beverages such as beer and wine?
Yes, Johnny's New York Style Pizza serves craft beer and wine for its customers.
How can I place an order online for Johnny's New York Style Pizza?
You can order online for takeout or delivery by visiting their website or directly through their order page at https://johnnys.orderexperience.net/54c42bbaeefd096e5fa6eb18/menu.
Where is Johnny's New York Style Pizza located in Athens, GA?
Johnny's New York Style Pizza is located at 1040 Gaines School Road, Suite 219, Athens, GA 30605, at the intersection of Gaines School Rd. and Cedar Shoals Dr.
What nearby ice cream shops can I visit before or after dining at Johnny's New York Style Pizza?
Nearby ice cream shops include Swirlee's Sweet & Frozen Treats of Athens, Lil Ice Cream Dude food truck, Cool's Ice Cream, and Baskin-Robbins, perfect for a dessert treat before or after your pizza meal.
Are there other dining options near Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Athens?
Yes, nearby dining options include Taste of India (Indian cuisine), Mirko Pasta (Italian), Siri Thai Cuisine (Thai), Frank and Sons Neighborhood Bistro (American bistro), and Your Pie (pizza and salad bar).
What nearby places of interest can visitors explore around Johnny's New York Style Pizza?
Visitors can explore nearby places such as East Athens Jiu Jitsu martial arts club, Beloved Salon & Spa, Dragon Star Hobbies, Tranquility Massage and Wellness spa, and Ansonborough of Athens landmark and shopping area.