Most customers praised the food as delicious and well-prepared, although there were a few complaints about specific dishes being cold or lacking flavor.
Service Excellence
The majority of reviews highlighted exceptional service, with many servers receiving specific praise for their attentiveness and friendliness.
Atmosphere
Customers appreciated the welcoming and clean environment, contributing to a pleasant dining experience.
Consistency
Many patrons noted the consistent quality of food and service over multiple visits, indicating a reliable dining option.
DC
David Castillo
2 days ago
5.0
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Wonderful Italian Dining Experience Thank You Rhonda!!!
This Italian restaurant delivers an authentic and memorable experience from start to finish. The pasta was perfectly cooked, rich in flavor, and clearly made with fresh ingredients. A delicious balance of sauce and cheese, just like in Italy.
The atmosphere was warm and inviting, and the staff were friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu. Portions were generous, prices were reasonable, and the dessert was outstanding.
Highly recommended for anyone looking for genuine Italian cuisine and great service. Again thank you Rhonda
JO
Jenine Obeid
6 days ago
5.0
Literally got in my car from Olive Garden to eat here and it was amazing. Parker was a great server.
DK
Dora Kinsler
Jan 5, 2026
5.0
I brought my Daughter in for her Birthday. It was our first time in. Our server was very knowledgeable and made several wonderful suggestions. We started with the Tomato Caprese with Fresh Burrata it was perfect. She had the Italian Classic trio. And I had the Scallops we loved every bite from start to finish. We had Tiramisu for dessert, the only thing we didn't care for was the chocolate shavings on top it totally took away from the deliciousness of what we felt was true Italian Tiramisu. We will definitely be back!!!
EH
Erin Haag
Dec 19, 2025
5.0
We visited carabba’s on Wednesday night for the first time in many, many years. Now I have no idea why we waited so long! The service was amazing. When there was an issue with my food, the staff went above and beyond trying to fix it and wanting us to return. We will definitely return! Everything was delicious. Wish I had grabbed our waitresses name, but it seemed everyone was very friendly. Great job!
JB
j benz
Dec 15, 2025
1.0
I’ve been eating at Carraba’s for almost 20 years. Worst experience I’ve ever had there tonight.
Walked in around 7:30 p.m. to having the manager oddly staring at my fiancé with some sort of strange look on his face, as if we were some kind of problem?
Next, we ordered an appetizer from one of the girls helping the bartender, who was serving our table on the floor (wild), never got it.
Our food tasted like it was microwaved. Half hot, half cold. Gross.
My water wasn’t refilled during the entire time I was eating my meal. Literally a small glass of water to start the evening and didn’t have it filled back up until we were about to get handed our check.
Lastly, as we walked out, no one said thank you for coming or anything of the sorts. Just the greeters doing something behind the desk and that strange manger again, just staring at us as we walked out.
12/15/25 is the last day I’ll eat at Carraba’s in Athens.