Pizzitalia's

Reviews

• AP

  Ann Marie Power

  1 day ago
  1.0
  I have eaten out half my life and only the 2nd time I've left a bad review which is necessary. I only came here because of the reviews which are obviously fake. Food and service were horrible. The workers don't seem to care about either. The large meatball Parmigiana Subs have barely any cheese and the meatballs themselves are sliced in 3rds or 4ths as shown; in order to spread them out. The cause on the side was only filled about 1/4 at most. I should have checked before I drove home 30 minutes so i would have gotten my money back. Lesson learned!
• RN

  Raj Nadkarni

  3 days ago
  5.0
  This little hole in the wall pizza joint was incredible. Maria was our server, she was so knowledgeable about how the food was prepared. The pizza was outstanding. A New York/New Jersey style with a Florida twist. It looks small from the parking lot but I recommend and latest that the good will blow your mind. Excellent surprise highly recommend
• TE

  Tony Elkabetz

  3 days ago
  1.0
  The worst experience I never had I called to ask what takes so long after 45 min of waiting and the delivery guy waiting 15 minutes outside already… the lady on the phone didn’t even ask my order number just said i need to be patient and talked nasty to me and before she hung up up she said and don’t come or call us again !!!! They need to be out of business for that
• VP

  VL Paralegal

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Sooo I ordered some food on doordash and we were so happy we found this spot! The spaghetti and meatballs, the salad, garlic knots and cannolis were all on point! I miss my Italian food from NY & NJ so much, so this brought me back ❣️🥲 The garlic knots were thicker and alot more doughier than I am used to.. but not bad. We can't wait to dine in soon.
• SG

  Susan Gates

  Feb 24, 2026
  4.0
  Went here to dine in with 2 other adults and 2 toddlers. Overall it was a pretty good experience. The service was slow and lacking though, and I'm fairly certain they forgot part of the order because the last thing to come out was the kids pizza, which really kind of ruined the experience for us, since our toddlers were screaming for food. There appeared to only be one waitress though. The pizza itself was good (we got the steak pizza) and the marinara was tasty. The atmosphere was fine. We'll probably return for the food but likely only for take out.