UNCLE MIKE'S PIZZERIA

Reviews

• MS

  Michael Sachs

  6 days ago
  3.0
  Decided to give this place a try ordered a meatball hand tossed Pizza and a calabrese salad. Don't want to be disparaging but mozzarella was kinda grainy and pizza wasn't very good. Talked to my neighbor who said his personal Pizza is pretty good but the meatball sandwich wasn't so he only gets that. Again not trying to blow up a business but I think the customer deserves to know what they are getting.
• SD

  S D

  Apr 8, 2026
  1.0
  The pizza was extremely dry and not very good. After buying, I read several reviews that mentioned the same issue. I definitely wish I had seen those before ordering.
• AC

  Allie C

  Apr 5, 2026
  4.0
  Good pizza and not like anyone else, they tasted great, different sauces and tasted good by the way, the garlic bread was cheesy and different but tasted great. The place is nicely decorated, staff is lovely, it sucks they don't serve medium size but only small and personal size, maybe a little pricey for my taste but I'd come back to check the rest of the menu.
• LP

  Linda Podoleski

  Apr 4, 2026
  1.0
  I went there today to order a quick slice of pizza to go. I had never had their pizza and thought I’d try a slice and if I liked it, I would come back with my family for dinner in the future. I live in the village, and when I got home and opened the box, it was burnt and dried out. Since I live close by, I went back to see about getting a fresh slice. The person working there was very rude to me. He said it “looks worse than it tastes. You should try it anyway.” I was expecting him to apologize and just replace the slice! I was flabbergasted! I said to him you shouldn’t be contradicting a customer. You should just offer to replace it. I showed the slice to the people around me at the bar and they were appalled at the fact that they would give me a burnt out dried piece of pie and his behavior. He replied that it is 4 PM now we don’t do slices anymore and handed me my money. I was so upset and stated that I won’t ever come here again. He replied “ I don’t care.” Well, if this is the way they treat customers I will never set foot in that shop again and I will tell all of my neighbors here in Westchase village not to visit this establishment.
• LS

  Lanette S

  Apr 3, 2026
  5.0
  First time ordering, won't be the last. I ordered the #BOGO 1 special which is an XL 3 topping and a L Pepperoni or Cheese pizza for $29.99. I ordered the XL thin crust and L hand tossed. I was totally amazed at the size of the thin crust. It is the largest "flat bread" that I have ever seen. It fantastic and feed 3 of us with leftovers. (The hand tossed is tomorrows lunch!) I will definitely be ordering from them again. Thanks for the dinner (forgot to take pics, we were starving!)