Customers consistently praised the food for its authenticity and flavor, highlighting dishes like birria tacos and handmade tortillas.
Service Issues
Many reviews noted slow service and inconsistencies, with some customers experiencing long wait times for food and poor attention from staff.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as cozy and inviting, with a pleasant outdoor seating area, contributing to a positive dining experience.
Portion Sizes
Several customers commented on small portion sizes, particularly for the price, leading to some disappointment.
BA
B A
Jan 3, 2026
1.0
Ordered online thru restaurant. It said my order would be ready by 3:04 according to the text message i received, but when I arrived I was told that they just received my order and that was about 3:20 when I got there. They said it would be about 20 more minutes before my order was actually ready. I said, ok no problem, I will come back. It was ready by the time i returned. I was excited to try their food due to some positive reviews. I ended up being disappointed. The chicken quesadilla looked like a soft taco with chicken, lettuce, and tomato. The chicken burrito was too wet that it soaked the tortilla tremendously. The chicken tamale was way to thick and did not have enough meat. It looked like a teaspoon of meat under all that bread. The Mexican street corn was bland and had too many strings in it. Overall, not a great experience.
AA
AC
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
Great local place for years in Tallahassee
TJ
Tyrell Jackson
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
When something is great it goes unsaid. And that’s exactly what happens when it comes to this wonderful place with food that will ignite anyone’s palate! Just amazing definitely recommend to enjoy meals here with friends and family!
LL
Latia Lee
Dec 19, 2025
5.0
Delicious and Great Service!
MM
Megan Murphy
Nov 25, 2025
3.0
Service is very very slow but the food is delicious. Seems like maybe one person in the kitchen who makes everything to order. So maybe not good for a large party but if you have time and are willing to wait then probably a decent spot.
Frequently Asked Questions About La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant
What are the regular business hours of La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant?
La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant is open Tuesday to Thursday from 10:30 AM to 9:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM. It is closed on Mondays.
Does La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What are the takeout hours for La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant?
Takeout is available Tuesday through Thursday from 10:30 AM to 9:00 PM, Friday and Saturday from 10:30 AM to 10:00 PM, and Sunday from 11:15 AM to 4:45 PM. The restaurant is closed for takeout on Mondays.
Where is La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant located?
La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant is located at 1840 N Monroe St, Tallahassee, FL 32303, United States.
Where can I view the menu and place an order for La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant?
You can view the menu and place an order online at https://latienditatally.com/menu.
What type of cuisine does La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant offer?
La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant serves Mexican cuisine including Tex-Mex, breakfast, tacos, burritos, seafood, vegetarian options, desserts, and also offers catering services.
What is the price range for dining at La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant?
The price range at La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant is considered to be moderate (Price Range Two).
Are there any interesting dining options near La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant?
Nearby dining options include Via Brazil, a Brazilian restaurant and cafe, Barnacle Bill's Seafood Restaurant, a seafood restaurant, Paris Banh Mi, an Asian bakery and restaurant, and Wendy's, a fast food burger restaurant.
What entertainment options are near La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant?
Nearby entertainment includes Tallahassee Midtown Arcade, an arcade and arts venue, and Altitude Trampoline Park, an amusement park and festival site, perfect for family outings before or after dining.
Are there any nearby services that could be convenient when visiting La Tiendita Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, nearby services include Green Dragon Dispensary for retail cannabis products, Northwood Animal Hospital if you need pet care, and United States Postal Service for mailing needs, all within close proximity to the restaurant.