Customers frequently praised the pizza for its delicious taste, authentic Chicago style, and quality ingredients, although some noted inconsistencies in preparation and flavor.
Service Experience
Many reviews highlighted excellent customer service, with staff being friendly, attentive, and accommodating, although there were some complaints about slow service during busy times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally described as welcoming and enjoyable, with outdoor seating options and a casual vibe that customers appreciated.
Pricing Concerns
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with rising prices and perceived value, mentioning that the portion sizes seemed smaller and that additional charges for substitutions were not clearly communicated.
Delivery and Pickup
While many customers had positive experiences with delivery and pickup, there were notable complaints about delays and order inaccuracies.
JK
Jacob Kimbark
Nov 17, 2025
5.0
If you from Chicago and mis Chicago style food, then you'll love it here. If your not from Chicago you'll still love
MM
Marge Milam
Nov 16, 2025
5.0
Love the Pizza. From Elgin, Illinois. 35 miles NW of Chicago. Love the Pizza so much but need to try the Italian Beef! I have dined in and taken out.
AL
Alyne H. Lewis
Nov 10, 2025
5.0
We always get take out! Our favorite is the Magnificent Meat!! Always delicious!!
PG
Pizza Girl
Nov 5, 2025
1.0
Pizza was greasy, pepperonis were not good. Crust wasn’t as crispy as I would have expected from a Chicago. Sauce was just okay.. Maybe I went on an off day. Ian and kyes is where I’ll continue to go for my Chicago fix.
DO
Dawn Alba Gary's Law Alba Law Office
Oct 24, 2025
5.0
Okay so today I come to this restaurant and Katie this amazing server is one of the most amazing angelic people I've ever met in my life. She took care of me like I was a queen today. If you're ever in need of somewhere to go where you will feel like you are so awesome, come here to this place and be treated like the queen that you are.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pusateri's Chicago Pizza
What are the regular business hours for Pusateri's Chicago Pizza?
Pusateri's Chicago Pizza is open Monday through Saturday from 11:30 AM to 8:00 PM, and on Sunday from 12:00 PM to 8:00 PM.
Does Pusateri's Chicago Pizza offer delivery and takeout services?
Yes, Pusateri's Chicago Pizza offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What are the delivery hours for Pusateri's Chicago Pizza?
Delivery is available Monday through Saturday from 11:30 AM to 7:30-7:50 PM depending on the day, and on Sunday from 12:00 PM to 7:45 PM.
Are there any special holiday closures for Pusateri's Chicago Pizza?
Yes, Pusateri's Chicago Pizza is closed on several major holidays including Thanksgiving Day (November 26), the day after Thanksgiving, Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, and New Year's Eve every year.
Where is Pusateri's Chicago Pizza located?
Pusateri's Chicago Pizza is located at 221 SE Ocean Blvd, Stuart, FL 34994, United States.
Can customers order Pusateri's Chicago Pizza online?
Yes, customers can order online via their website at https://pusaterispizza.com/menu.
Which city does Pusateri's Chicago Pizza primarily serve?
Pusateri's Chicago Pizza primarily serves the city of Sewall's Point, FL.
What local landmarks or government offices are near Pusateri's Chicago Pizza?
Nearby landmarks include the Martin County Courthouse and the Department of Motor Vehicles, which customers may visit before or after dining at Pusateri's Chicago Pizza.
Are there any nearby dining options similar to Pusateri's Chicago Pizza?
Yes, Pepe & Sale is an Italian restaurant and wine bar located near Pusateri's Chicago Pizza, offering additional dining choices.
What shopping and service places are close to Pusateri's Chicago Pizza that customers might visit?
Nearby businesses include Francesca Morgan Interiors and Mel-Ry Construction, which customers can visit for interior design or home improvement needs along with enjoying pizza at Pusateri's.