Carmelas Brick Oven Pizza

Reviews

• PC

  Paul Hemmers, food critique

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Over many years we recently noticed a huge influx of traffic at their location. Decided to order their large pizza. Price is comparable to 2 medium pies from other competitors. We were delighted with the flavor and crust was very different but very nice texture and the chew starts towards the edges. The only complaint we have is the pizza boxes are a bit too small and the edge was folded over, hopefully they will find a larger box to accommodate the pizza. Wasn’t a huge deal on our part. Highly recommend this location in stuart.
• MB

  Michael Brower

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Went to eat at Carmelas as it has been a while since my last time, and I was not disappointed. Had their fried ravioli and grandmas white bacon pizza (sorry if i got the name wrong! *heart*). Cooked perfectly and flavorful. No greasiness and loved the slight char on the crust. Great dining, atmosphere (saw someone celebrating a birthday) and services. I recommend people to come try it or come back if you haven't in while like myself.
• MK

  Mark Kleine

  Mar 31, 2026
  4.0
  The girl at the checkout was not friendly at all. Even after I spent $176 on four pizzas.
• GA

  Gary Armstrong

  Mar 27, 2026
  5.0
  Carmela’s has THE BEST Sicilian pizza in the area! Their food is great too, but the Sicilian pie is the star of the show! I lived in NY for 50+ years so pizza is life! Give it a try if you from up north.
• TR

  T Rock

  Mar 18, 2026
  3.0
  I've been a regular since they opened. Usually we order full pies but tonight I got 2 slices to go. As I was walking out I thought to myself this bag is really light. There was a time that 2 slices was quite hearty but not anymore. These were puny, 7" across with 3" of crust. Very disappointing.