Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• KS

  Kevin Shaner

  6 days ago
  3.0
  Ordered on the app 4/2/2026, special going on for a “BOGO” large special. I ordered the “Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo pizza” this was the first time I’ve ever been unable to finish a pizza. Not because I was full but because of the lack of taste, sauce cold, & missing all the flavor. This could’ve been a “me problem” but I doubt it. Other major issue, that you can read about in most of the other reviews—“under cooked”. I thought it wasn’t true but I was very surprised when the cheese & the spinach pie were still doughy. I even clicked on both pizzas to have them cooked “well done” & I still got under cooked pizzas. The service was great, pizza was ready 10 minutes before I arrived & the gentleman was very quick to greet me as I walked in. The Inside waiting room is pretty small but hey it’s for takeout only I guess. *beware, the BOGO deals always have a hidden disclaimer when it comes to taste* *don’t get the Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo pizza
• BP

  Bailey P

  Mar 21, 2026
  1.0
  Ordered through DoorDash. Ordered one of our pizzas with no cheese but they put cheese on anyway, had to throw it out.
• LW

  Lourdes Welch

  Mar 7, 2026
  3.0
  The flavor of the pizza overall was good. The pie was extremely undercooked. The pizza tasted a little doughy and the cheese didn’t taste cook all the way.
• KD

  K D

  Feb 28, 2026
  1.0
  I saw a doordasher come in returning a wrong order and the Hispanic girl behind the counter put it back on the shelf to be delivered. Shouldn't she have tossed it and remade that order. You don't really know what that doordasher could have done to the pizza.
• AW

  Angela West

  Jan 18, 2026
  5.0
  I truly want to take a moment to thank the manager who took my order. He went above and beyond to help me—not only correcting an error I made when placing the order online, but personally delivering it to my home. Even though the mistake was mine, he took the time to fix it without hesitation and brought it himself on a cold, rainy day. I didn’t get the chance to tell him how much this meant to me. My son was sick, and I wasn’t able to leave the house, so his kindness truly made a difference for our family. Thank you for taking the time to do something you didn’t have to do. I genuinely appreciate you, and I will definitely continue ordering pizza from your company!

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza