Many customers praised the pizza for its delicious taste, great crust, and generous toppings.
Service
The staff received positive feedback for being friendly and accommodating, with several customers highlighting excellent service.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mentioned concerns about the cleanliness of the restaurant, including dirty dining areas and bathrooms.
Pricing
Some customers felt the prices were high, especially with additional charges for payment methods, while others found the value acceptable.
Takeout Experience
The restaurant is noted as a good option for takeout, with many customers appreciating the convenience and quality of food for takeout orders.
JJ
Jason Joseph
2 days ago
1.0
Throws some fresh cheese on top of yesterday's pie and serves it! Not exactly fresh. I'm from NY and have had plenty of great pizza and this place falls w/In the worst 2 places I've ever been. Even the sauce sucks in my humble opinion. Also found something extremely hard in my pizza and literally have no idea what it was
LK
Liz K
Feb 1, 2026
2.0
We called and ordered 5 items. We reviewed the order at least 3 times with the staff member who answered the phone. When we picked up, only 2 items had been prepared. We had to take those items home and then return to pick up the other items. The pizza was cold and congealed when we got it home 5 minutes away. Aside from apologies from the staff no reparations were offered, no discount for our inconvenience and no offer to deliver the food they forgot to make. If it had been hot, my GF white specialty pizza would have been delicious.
SS
S Sameh E Sarah
Jan 29, 2026
5.0
By far the Best pizza in town & Owner is a real nice guy, too!! Highly recommend!!
MG
Mike gary
Jan 26, 2026
5.0
Man O Man!!! So we rode up from Fernandina to try this place out, first timers, we used pictures and reviews as our decision to try it. Wow soo glad we did, absolutely amazingly delicious pizza I've had in a long time (if ever). Totally blown away by the ingredients, taste, even the seasoning that the young lady put on the pie. I can't say enough about the whole experience. We all was licking our plates. My thoughts on the way home was "How do i get this pizza freshly made back in yulee"? Thanks for providing us with such a good pizza. Vinnys pizza= 10 stars..
CC
CarsNStuff
Jan 12, 2026
2.0
First and last visit. Would have paid cash if I had known I'd be charged an extra $1 to pay with debit on top of their already highish prices. Place is small; only 3 tables and kind of dirty. Ceiling tiles needs replacing; bathroom wasn't particularly clean. Hoagie was mid at best. Giving 2 stars instead of 1 because the marinara sauce was pretty good.