Five Star Pizza - Sarasota

Reviews

• AL

  Amanda Lasko

  3 days ago
  4.0
  Received the wrong pizza topping, they made it right ! Appreciate them taking care of there costumers
• BB

  Brenna Beardsley

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  No nonsense, consistent quality, they've never been late, and they've never messed up an order... That's why we keep coming back 😁
• MF

  Megen Fountain

  Mar 28, 2026
  5.0
  Not the first time we've swung by this location, five star pizza is our favorite! We just dont have one near us in Lee County :( Travelling by, and had to make the pit stop for the best pizza. Thanks again!!
• WR

  Wesley Rodrigo

  Mar 26, 2026
  5.0
  After my initial disappointment, I want to update my review. 5 Star Pizza quickly responded and sent a fresh replacement pizza, which arrived promptly and was absolutely perfect. I appreciate their follow-up and commitment to customer service. I’m raising my rating because, in the end, they made it right, and I respect that effort.
• MG

  Megan Green

  Mar 25, 2026
  3.0
  We ordered 3 pizzas to be delivered to us after getting a very cute card with a coupon inside for $9 dollars off. 2 pizzas were fine....I guess.....too much cheese for my taste... but the 3rd pizza was ruined. Cheese all over the top of it. We also ordered pepperoni rolls that came inside a Styrofoam container that looked like they took garlic butter and literally poured it over the foiled food inside, the garlic butter was dumping out the side of the container. I changed my review to 3 stars instead of 1 because the food itself is not bad. The crust was cooked fine and the ingredients were fresh. Probably won't order delivery from them again but the pizza is fine.