Numerous customers reported issues with food freshness, including cold and overcooked items, leading to dissatisfaction.
Service Issues
Many reviews highlighted long wait times for service and food, as well as understaffing and poor management responses.
Cleanliness
Several customers noted unsanitary conditions in the restaurant, including dirty tables and unpleasant odors.
Mixed Experiences
While some customers praised specific servers and enjoyed their meals, many expressed disappointment with the overall experience, indicating inconsistency in service and food quality.
MB
Madison Burgess
Jan 5, 2026
3.0
I just finished picking up my takeout order. I normally love this location as it's always lively and the atmosphere is amazing! The service is usually very good...
But tonight was not...
I'd placed an order over the phone and whoever the gentleman was that I spoke to was absolutely lovely! I was actually looking forward to meeting him when I came to pick up my food. When I walked in the takeout door, I saw two other people waiting in line for their order and I waited at the counter...then waited about five minutes more. Another gentleman came in to pick up his food as well. All of us waiting for all the very long time. Mind you, THERE WERE WORKERS THERE near the front area looking at us ...and we (waiting for our food orders) looked back at them like "HELLO?" Can we get some help over here?
Eventually one woman came over and asked us all of our names for our orders and disappeared to the back...
There was no "sorry for the wait" or, "so sorry we had to figure something out with the orders".
Now let's be perfectly clear, this is a Monday, so it's not busy in the restaurant either. They're about maybe two other people in booths eating while the rest of us were waiting for our to go orders. We finally get our food, I pay, and leave, and go directly to my car to write this review.
I've worked in the hospitality industry for a very long time(restaurants, theme parks, and now hotels). So I get it, down time and slow times happen, but when there's literally a guest at the desk waiting for service, for food that they've paid for, you're just going to stand there? Unacceptable.
Yes, I will be returning because the wings are amazing here and that's why this is the only wing place that I actually like and it's close to my house as well. But please, get better wait staff or train them to be more efficient and alert. Thank you!
RC
R Crawford
Jan 2, 2026
5.0
Great service on New Year’s. We watched a whole football game. Our beer never was empty. Ashley was so nice - great service
BG
Buchika Gurr
Dec 23, 2025
1.0
I am writing this review because I genuinely care about health of customers still going to this place.
I went to BWW back in 2016 in California and food is delicious. I am back again after 10 yrs at lake Mary location.
I want to ask the restaurant. Are you sure that traditional wings are fresh. I can smell rotten meat, Chewy and not consumable for humans. May be rats and vultures. Please don’t go here people it’s not worth your health.
DB
Dustin Billinger
Dec 23, 2025
3.0
Food was alright this location always has a funny smell to it the three times we have been here.
TM
Tim McDoogle
Dec 21, 2025
1.0
Shut this place down!!!
This place is disgusting, food is not fresh. Bathroom was covered in throw up. Under staffed. 20 minutes wait to sit with an empty dining room.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Sanford, FL specialize in?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Sanford, FL specializes in award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings available in 26 different sauces and seasonings.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Sanford, Florida?
It is located at 1670 Rinehart Road, Sanford, FL 32771, United States.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in Sanford?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open from 11:00 AM to midnight Sunday through Thursday, and from 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM on Friday and Saturday.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings open on weekends?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings is open on weekends from 11:00 AM to 1:00 AM on Saturdays and 11:00 AM to midnight on Sundays.
What kind of restaurant is Buffalo Wild Wings categorized as?
Buffalo Wild Wings is categorized as a Chicken Wings Restaurant, Sports Bar, Restaurant, and Takeout restaurant.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Sanford?
You can contact Buffalo Wild Wings by phone at +1 407-330-3589.
Are there other dining options near Buffalo Wild Wings at 1670 Rinehart Road?
Yes, nearby dining options include Andy's Frozen Custard for desserts, Cheddar's Scratch Kitchen for American cuisine, Subway for sandwiches, China Star for Chinese food, Pa'lla Voy Restaurant for Puerto Rican and Caribbean dishes, Pizza Twist for pizza and burgers, and Pacino's Pizzeria for Italian cuisine.
What nearby entertainment or shopping options are available around Buffalo Wild Wings?
Nearby places include GameStop and Saint Johns Plaza - GameStop for video games and entertainment, Plato's Closet for thrift shopping, Funk Board Shop for skateboards and bicycles, and Brillare Jewelers for jewelry shopping.
Are there services nearby Buffalo Wild Wings for eyewear or health?
Yes, Visionworks offers optometry services and eyewear, while Burn Fat Orlando is a nutritionist and weight loss center nearby.
Where can customers visit before or after dining at Buffalo Wild Wings for coffee and relaxation?
Customers can visit Quigley Coffee Co., a nearby smoothie and juice bar, cafe, and coffee shop, to relax before or after their meal.