Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• HT

  HRH KING BOSCH THIRD

  3 days ago
  5.0
  I have nothing but great things to say about this location, on Jim Redman pkwy. The staff is kind and courteous, always willing to go the extra mile for their customers. No matter how busy they get, everyone still treats you like your just as important no matter how small your order is. Lucas and Ike especially have great customer service skills, I normally don't do well making up my mind but Lucas takes the time to go over all the options. Great staff, great food!
• CH

  Cornelius Hoffman

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Absolutely blown away by the incredible experience at Papa John’s in Plant City! From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere is welcoming and the service is phenomenally attentive. The pizza is nothing short of spectacular—perfectly baked crust, outrageously flavorful sauce, and toppings that taste unbelievably fresh. Every bite feels like a masterpiece of cheesy, saucy perfection. It’s the kind of place where you can instantly tell the team takes enormous pride in what they do. What truly makes this location extraordinary is the consistency and passion behind every order. The staff goes above and beyond with impressively fast service and genuinely friendly energy that makes you feel like a valued regular even on your first visit. If you’re craving pizza that is bold, mouthwatering, and absolutely unforgettable, the Plant City Papa John’s is a dazzling standout. It’s easily one of the most remarkable pizza experiences around!
• SM

  Samantha Mattson

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Very clean and organized store .. the service was on point and the employees are very nice and respectful when they talk and take your order. They made my order in a timely fashion and it was just what I ordered. I will definitely be ordering from there again.
• TF

  Tracy Forest

  Feb 27, 2026
  3.0
  I kept trying to find a reason to like Papa John’s, but tonight’s order seals it as a hard pass. I ordered on the app, but when hubs went to pick it up, there was apparently a long delay dealing with a difficult customer. By the time he got home, pizzas and wings were barely lukewarm. Even after putting pizzas back in the oven, the crusts were still soggy and all was swimming in grease. I’m done. Its just mediocre pizza at a jacked up price.
• SW

  Summer Wisehart

  Feb 25, 2026
  3.0
  Here’s my question with Papa John’s………… This is every time I go in there! They look miserable as hell My other question is, why are you flipping pizzas around on your arms with arm hair? I looked it up and it is not a standard procedure at Papa John’s. You’re supposed to stretch the dough with your knuckles, not your arm hair. The hygiene at this store is definitely lacking along with attitudes. I’ve been in there a few times and they have the worst hygiene procedures ever

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza