Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza

Reviews

• PC

  PeanutButter Croissant

  5 days ago
  5.0
  I ordered a wrap and the spaghetti and meatballs for me and my little brother, the food was super good and the wait time was only like 15 minutes. Very fast and Ava was sooooo cool and sweet. I enjoyed chatting it up, shes so personable :)) Give girly a raise! Meow meow
• DG

  Debra Greene

  Feb 23, 2026
  5.0
  Wow! We really liked Johnny Brusco's New York Style Pizza restaurant! Our service was top-notch by Sabrina, who was friendly, helpful, and efficient! We had the large Johnny Brusco's Speciality Pizza! It was delicious! We totally enjoyed the leftovers for a few more days! The yummy cinnamon bites are the best I've had! We're glad that Johnny Brusco's in Pensacola! You can join their rewards, too! Yay!
• EB

  Erin Butler

  Feb 13, 2026
  5.0
  Our new favorite pizza place in the area! It was delicious. Definitely had a NY style flavor. The crust was delicious. Personally, I like it better than Sky's. As an aside, I am from NY. I only bring it up because of a 1-star review from another who stated that he is also from NY and this is not NY style and how terrible it is. I disagree. Hopefully he just got a bad pie. Personally, this pizza reminded me of one of my all-time favorite places back home.
• JG

  J G

  Feb 12, 2026
  3.0
  Overall, not a bad experience at all! I enjoyed the atmosphere. Its a cute little place, very comfy, and it was well kept/clean. The staff was very polite and friendly. As far as the experience goes, thats where most of the positives are about this restaurant! The only reason I give it such a middle of the road score is because the food was kind of just that. It wasn't bad, per se, but for pizza in this area, there are too many better options for quality pizza for this place to stand out. My pizza was particularly heavy on the oil/grease, though the other people I ate with did not have as much oil in their food, though thats the most I can complain about. All in all, its definitely not a bad place to eat by any means, but especially being on the higher end of price, its going to have a tough go considering the pizza quality doesnt stand up to the multitude of better, cheaper options we have around here.
• JB

  Jamie Brown

  Feb 10, 2026
  3.0
  Fairly new establishment close to home so we were excited to try it. First the good: Noelle provided pretty good service and the Mediterranean salad was delicious and a good value for the price. Restaurant was clean. Now the not so great - we also ordered the Italian sub (the owners namesake sub) and were pretty disappointed at the lack of meat. Literally one small small piece of each meat- think 1/4” of meat and 2” of bun - and 8” at $13.50 not a good value at all. Very little meat and big bun. Next was the price on the pizza - $21.00 for a 12” pizza just seemed a little much considering the previous reviews…would have to be outstanding for the money. Bartender sat at the bar (when she was actually at the bar) and in between guests the hostess sat in a booth. Just not much energy. Might try again for the salad but will skip the big bun sub! They do have a liquor license - with a decent engaging bartender and some meal improvements would love to make this our hangout!