Sammy's Italian Restaurant and Pizza

Reviews

• TA

  Teresa A. Alvarado

  6 days ago
  5.0
  As always, pizza, salad, and manicott were all outstanding. Takeout service was excellent. We were shocked at the bill. .. under 30 bucks and fed 5 people. What a great deal and delicious meal. We love Sammy's!
• TS

  T William Silvia

  Feb 27, 2026
  1.0
  On our recent, and final, visit there, our waitress carried on a long conversation with friends. Another waitress finally brought over our pizza. It was cold. Rather than apologize, the original waitress became unglued and created a scene, refusing to further serve us, and loudly saying bad things about us to everyone in earshot range. When we tried to address her behavior we were told that she was the niece of the owner. Customers should not be treated this way. This is not how you run a business.
• GQ

  Ginny Q

  Feb 23, 2026
  5.0
  First time at Sammy's but it won't be the last. Got baked ziti, Italian wedding soup, a mini cannoli, and veal Parmesan sub. Everything was really good. Thanks for doing the cooking tonight! I'll be asking you again real soon! 😁
• GB

  Gilbert Barthelemy

  Feb 20, 2026
  5.0
  Being born in a taxi cab in the village in New York and raised in Brooklyn lived all my life over there I decided to throw in the towel and moved to Ocala with my wife I paid my dues and got tired of New York and then I found this pizzeria gem in Ocala not far from where me and my wife are and to be honest with you the tradition and delicious pizza and restaurant dishes at Sammy's is outstanding!!! I was very lucky to find this mom and pop pizzeria wouldn't trade it in a heartbeat Love it! I had the honor a meeting Paulie and congratulated him The staff is great The food is out of this world I love their sauce their muscles fried Diablo sauce not to mention that regular sauce is out of this world excellent Italian old fashioned delicious dinners do yourself a favor and have a cannoli for dessert another Jem in flavor and taste! Thank you for bringing the tradition and flavor of Brooklyn New York keep up the great work My wife and I are so happy we found such a great Italian old fashioned style pizzeria restaurant!
• DW

  Dee Westphal

  Feb 13, 2026
  5.0
  We've always enjoyed going to Sammys for dinner or lunch. The service is always top notch and the aromas wafting through the dining room are so tantalizing! Tonight I ordered a pizza for pickup on my way home from a long day. It was ready when they said it would be, piping hot and just waiting for my arrival. Again, those aromas hit you as you walk through the door.....almost wished we had decided on dine in. My son loves New York style and the first thing he commented was, I really like the crust. Im a thick crust person and I will say, those edges were perfectly delicious!!!! Just the right amount of char, chewy and tender....yummy!!! If you haven't been there...I urge you to enjoy their hospitality, you'll soon become a regular. And try their chicken parm, my fav dine-in. Bring a big appetite and plan to take some home. The portions are incredible! I love our local dining!

Frequently Asked Questions About Sammy's Italian Restaurant and Pizza