Customers consistently praised the freshness and deliciousness of the lobster rolls and other menu items.
Service
The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, attentive, and accommodating.
Portion Sizes
Many reviews highlighted the generous portions of lobster in the rolls, contributing to a good value for the price.
Overall Experience
Customers expressed a strong desire to return, indicating a high level of satisfaction with their dining experience.
EK
Elise K
3 days ago
5.0
We’re big lobster roll fans and like to try what we can when we’re in a new city. Highly recommend this place! Wonderful friendly service. Rolls made fresh to order. Lots of meat. Amazing flavour! We had a Connecticut and a Maine roll and couldn’t decide on our favourite.
JS
Jessica Sanchez
3 days ago
5.0
Laid back atmosphere & AMAZING lobster rolls. Phenomenal portion & lobster quality. Rare to find a quality lobster roll that has a lot of lobster meat & at a decent price. Highly recommend!
EJ
Eileen Jensen
Jan 5, 2026
5.0
The best lobster rolls we have had in Naples!....and we have hit every place that makes them!! Great portion, fresh buttered and grilled rollo, your choice of 3 sizes and the service was great. What more can you ask for?
JO
J.D Ovalle
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
Here’s everything we tried 👇
🦞 Connecticut Roll — fresh, tender lobster + melted butter — 9.3/10
🥣 Lobster Bisque — creamy, rich, more juicy lobster — 9.0/10
🥪 Italian Roll — pesto aioli + mozzarella = unreal — 9.5/10
🥔 Clam Chowder — insane flavor + warm potatoes — 9.7/10
🌶️ Deep South Roll — spicy, flavorful with jalapeños — 9.7/10
🍋 Key Lime Pie — soft, citrusy perfection — 9.3/10
Want to see the full video ? Check us out on Instagram. J.D_Ovalle
And TikTok: J.Dovalle1
KJ
Katherine S Jones
Dec 25, 2025
5.0
Amazing experience at Mystic Lobster Roll in Christmas time!!
We absolutely loved our experience at Mystic Lobster Roll. We are visiting from Texas, and this place truly exceeded our expectations. The service was warm, friendly, and attentive from the moment we arrived, we felt genuinely welcomed.
The food was outstanding: fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. You can really taste the quality and care in every bite. It’s the kind of place that makes you slow down, enjoy the moment, and appreciate great food made with love.
If you’re in Mystic, this spot is a must-visit. We will definitely be back and highly recommend it to anyone looking for an unforgettable lobster roll experience!
We come back