Mystic Lobster Roll Co - Naples, Vanderbilt Shoppes

Reviews

• SE

  Susan Eyer

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Mystic Lobster is a hidden gem in Naples. You would never know by the storefront how delicious their food is! I had the Lobster Bisque which was creamy and delicious and filled with chunks of fresh lobster. I also had the Connecticut Roll which was a soft roll filled with lots of warm Lobster with butter. It also came with a side of coleslaw. If you are looking for a Lobster treat off the beaten path definitely consider Mystic Lobster Roll!
• DD

  Diane

  3 days ago
  5.0
  The lobster rolls here are delicious. The lobster is so tender and tasty. We ordered a regular size Deep South roll and a large Connecticut roll with just butter on a toasted roll. Both were perfect and we can’t wait to eat here again!
• TS

  Tracey Steller

  6 days ago
  5.0
  I came in near the end of the day and was greeted warmly and given the option to dine in when many restaurants would insist on take out. I got the warm CT style 6" roll. It was standard pricing I've seen for lobster roll in New England. The bun was tasty and there was enough lobster claw meat to be satisfying. The staff were warm and welcoming. If I'm in the area again I will be sure to stop by.
• GT

  G T

  Mar 9, 2026
  5.0
  The atmosphere is somewhat simple and a bit uncomfortable. But the lobster rolls are 10 stars. Simply so delicious. 😋 No - unbelievably delicious. And that has been the case over the many times I have been there. Always consistently reliable quality that never had a fishy taste. Lobster lovers know exactly what I mean. 🦞
• MH

  Martina Hedvicek

  Mar 6, 2026
  5.0
  Ordered takeout from here and had a larger order--two classic Maine rolls, a shrimp quesadilla, bacon Maine lobster bites, a lobster salad and a clam chowder and lobster bisque. Everything came out delicious, the servings were large and they were generous with the lobster meat. The two young men working were very pleasant, but I didn't get their names.