Hemingway's Tavern

Reviews

• MF

  Marianne Mistretta Futo

  Apr 20, 2026
  3.0
  The food was ok. My main issue is that the prices are much too high for what is being served. It is ridiculous for fries to not come with the sandwich.
• AS

  Andrea “Concierge” S

  Apr 18, 2026
  5.0
  My first time here. Ate at bar; VERY fast & super friendly service by Alyssa! She set the tone for an enjoyable experience! Made me feel welcome & asked if food was OK & what else I needed: golden service. Will be back. I lived in Key West; you can tour Hemingway’s beautiful home. Photos & Hemingway memorabilia are wonderful at this restaurant. All staff are well trained & welcoming; you feel appreciated. It’s a huge place; I expected it to be tiny, like places in Key West with Hemingway photos, etc. displayed. You feel wrapped in the love for Hemingway’s here! Try to arrive EARLY for Happy Hour which ends at 6:29. Huge parking lot was packed. Mimosas are not on HH, so I only ordered delicious food. I suggest adding mimosas to HH, for those of us who don’t drink alcohol except mimosas as a treat. Best service in Brevard County by Alyssa. She’s a huge asset to your business, by building new, repeat, loyal customers. The menu has many wonderful choices. Next time I’ll order the fish.
• LS

  Lou S

  Apr 17, 2026
  5.0
  I had seen they had a good Cuban sandwich. It was good but much smaller size bread and serving inside, but it was filling enough for a lite lunch. $24 with soda and tip. First time there it's a nice room and it seems like there are other things on the menu I would like
• KV

  Kedia Valido

  Apr 10, 2026
  5.0
  This is one my and my husband's faaaavorite restaurant. They offer a wide variety of food as well as a few vegetarian options. Tonight however, we had an amazing server, Deein. He was super attentive, very kind, and very accommodating (i usually have a lot of alterations to my meal). Deein made sure everything was correct and checked in often. I look forward to seeing him again!
• JR

  Joel Robinson

  Apr 7, 2026
  2.0
  Okay so I've been wanting to try Hemingways for a while and we finally did it last weekend the service was excellent the atmosphere was nice but the star of the show was supposed to be the food and drink I got the three signature items a mojito that was too sweet to drink practically and they used sour mix instead of sugar water which is why it was too sweet and you're never supposed to use sour mix to make a mojito then I got the crab dip and I proceeded to put the toasted bread in the crap dip and nothing got on my bread because it was sitting under the heat lamp for too long I guess, so I had to use a knife and it was not very good. lastly I got the Hemingway snapper dish which is their signature dish I guess and the fish was not flaky and soft it was extremely tough and the sauce was bland. My kids got a burger and Cuban sandwich on my wife got the fried snapper and they all agreed it was blah. Not sure why this place has such amazing reviews but we will not be returning.