Customers consistently praised the deliciousness and quality of the sandwiches, particularly the Philly cheesesteak and Italian sub.
Customer Service
The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, courteous, and attentive, contributing positively to the overall dining experience.
Cleanliness
Many reviews highlighted the cleanliness of the establishment, noting a well-maintained environment.
Management Changes
Recent changes in ownership have led to improvements in food quality and service, with several customers expressing satisfaction with the new management.
Inconsistencies
Some customers reported issues with order accuracy and service speed, indicating room for improvement in operational efficiency.
TA
Teresa Adams
Jan 1, 2026
5.0
This Mary Esther store is anazing. It was so clean today! It was staffed with very pleasant people and the food was fresh and made perfectly to order!
MT
Marshall R. Taylor
Dec 29, 2025
5.0
$10 for a lunch combo in 2025? Yes, please.. Polite staff, fresh ingredients (bread is great), clean and pleasant atmosphere.
TA
Teresa Amrhein
Dec 22, 2025
5.0
This is as close to home made as I could make it myself.
Clean and cozy eating establishment..... Love it!!!
CB
Chino Barber
Dec 18, 2025
5.0
I've been coming here since I moved in to town and they have never disappoint. Awesome Philly cheese steak sandwich! 🤤
JJ
Jalisa Jones
Nov 25, 2025
5.0
My coworkers and I decided to have a Philly-cheesteak blind taste test.
We called it Operation Liberty Steak. Our objective, "To liberate our tastebuds from inferior cheesesteaks"
We each picked a sandwich from one of the local area restaurants, and I chose Lenny's.
I walk in to Lenny's, explain what we're doing, ask for a plain cheeseteak and said, "I need to you to put your foot in this". Malissa, the woman working the register said, " I'm going to make this one myself" and asked another worker to finish ringing me up. She went to the kitchen and went to WORK. I asked the woman who finished ringing me up if they by chance had some food grade gloves so we could slice up the sandwiches, I didn't get her name but she was SOOOO SWEET. Not only did she give me two pairs of gloves, but she provided two different sizes, wrapped them in wax paper, and LABELED THEM BY SIZE.
A few minutes later Malissa hands me the order and says, "you're going to win".
Fastforward the the blind taste test. The rules were simple, it had to be a plain cheesteak, we tasted them blindfolded, had to guess where it came from, and rate it based on several categories.
The categories were:
Customer service
Bread quality
Flavor
We discussed the customer service prior to the tasting and Lenny's was already pulling ahead because they were so fantastic to me.
Nobody accurately guessed Lenny's when we tasted it but the flavor was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS and got compliments from most of the "tasters". We were actually terrible at guessing where the sandwiches came from. The only one I got correct came from a pizza restaurant and thats because it literally tasted like pizza, I think they use pizza crust dough for the bread and the pizza cheese on the sandwich but thats just speculation lol.
Anyways, out of 6 cheesesteaks LENNYS WON OVERALL. The customer service was amazing, the bread was soft and delicIous, and the flavor was savory and perfectly seasoned. One of my coworkers is a die-hard fan of a another restaurant so he prevented Lennys from being everyone's top choice but he's a hater and his opinion doesn't matter.
I say all this to say, if you want to liberate your tastebuds from inferior cheesesteaks, GO TO LENNY'S.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Lennys Grill & Subs?
Nearby places include Taryn Leigh Esthetics (beauty salon), Boardwalk Vapes FWB (e-cigarette store), and Seaside Spine (chiropractor). You can visit these for beauty treatments, vape products, or chiropractic care along with your dining experience.
Are there other sandwich shops near Lennys Grill & Subs?
Yes, nearby sandwich shops include Lennys Subs, Schlotzsky's, and Circle K, offering a variety of sandwich options close to Lennys Grill & Subs.