Mahina

Reviews

• BW

  Brett Wilson

  2 days ago
  5.0
  Had a wonderful dinner here last evening. Food was excellent and our server, Tiffany, went out of her way to make us comfortable. It was a cool and windy evening, but we still wanted to sit outside. She repositioned heaters and brought blankets to make us comfortable. Strongly recommend this wonderful location.
• DL

  Dan Lima

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Tiffany was a fantastic server. She accommodated us every step of the way from our wine requests, to making sure we got our orders out right. Kevin took our picture and was very friendly. Pedro their manager made sure we had a great evening as well. Not to mention the food was delicious but we all know you come back for the service.
• IM

  Ing. Dominika Morrow

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Everything was lovely. I recommend to come here for the sunset - it’s magical. I celebrated my birthday here and Tiffany took amazing care of us. She gave us time. Food was excellent - I highly recommend the whole snapper. It’s outstanding dish. I also received dessert - key lime pie. Delicious. I felt very special. Thank you Mahina and Tiffany for making my birthday special.
• SK

  SHAWN KIM

  Feb 17, 2026
  5.0
  Our dinner at Mahina was perhaps the highlight of our dining experience in the Keys. We chose the catch and cook option from our fishing trip earlier that day, and it was prepared beautifully. Aside from the fish, we also ordered a filet mignon and a shrimp scampi, which were both delicious as well. We ordered two desserts at the end of the night, and the flourless chocolate cake and key lime pie were one of the best. On top of that, the service was absolutely exceptional. Many thanks to Surama and Pedro, who were amazing servers and always made sure that we were having the best experience possible!
• TH

  tim holdsworth

  Feb 14, 2026
  5.0
  We have been to Mahina multiple times over the last few years and we came to the conclusion that it’s the best atmosphere for dinner on the water anywhere in the Keys. We start inside at the bar for a great cocktail and the drinks and service are always impeccable. The dinner was the delicious. if I have one critique and this is not anything against our server. The service time can improve some. Im not sure if the servers have too many tables but they are great but just wish we could have a little more attention but I’d recommend Mahina to anyone