Most customers praised the pizza and Italian dishes as delicious, with many noting the authentic New York style.
Service
Service received mixed reviews; while many highlighted friendly and attentive staff, some reported long wait times and poor service experiences.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mentioned the establishment as clean and well-maintained, although there were isolated complaints about unsanitary practices.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as cozy and welcoming, with a family-friendly vibe and live music events that enhance the dining experience.
Pricing
Customers generally found the prices reasonable for the quality of food, though a few felt certain items were overpriced.
GG
Ginny Gerlach
3 days ago
5.0
This was our first time ordering pizza and having it delivered. We ordered 3 different large pizzas that were delicious and still hot. Delivery driver was very pleasant
JC
Jami Clark
4 days ago
1.0
Website didn't work so I called to order. They told me to order on the website. I told them their website didn't work. They said try again. I told them if tried multiple times and asked if I could just order by phone. This was not possible so I never ordered.
MD
M. Defranco
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
Have been ordering pizza from Brooklyn Pizzeria in Leesburg, FL for a couple of years.
Pizza is consistently great and on time, and the service is always friendly and professional.
Highly recommend.
Manny D
CN
Cindy Neal
Dec 31, 2025
5.0
Our first visit..and it was an online, order to go! But what a charming place!!! Next time we will dine in!! Pizza was delicious!
HM
Heather M
Dec 29, 2025
3.0
Just ordered the garlic knots and honestly they were awful for "garlic" knots. Not a lick of garlic or any kind of seasoning on them. Just bread with cheese. Extremely disappointing.