Brooklyn's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Reviews

• EM

  Eileen Murphy

  5 days ago
  3.0
  We arrived on a Friday evening with understanding that the place is usually busy on Friday nights. However, we waited more than 45 minutes for our food. Waitress didn't come to our table to ask if we wanted refills on our drinks. Avoided us mostly. Kept saying they were working on it. Then she brought us a Pizza, which we did not order. It was for another table. Once we got our food, we were told that they ran out of Spaghetti. Really? An Italian Pizza place that should have full stock of everything???? Unless that's the just the story we were told. If she would've come back and asked if we wanted some other type of pasta, we would've let her know with no problem. The food was delicious, no issues there. But the service was not good. We believe some of the staff should be trained a little better. We will return again as we do like their food. Just needed to point out the service.
• AT

  Amber Torres

  Feb 22, 2026
  5.0
  Went for the first time last night and will definitely be back! I have Celiac (gluten allergy) - they have GF cauliflower crust and GF penne and spaghetti. I tried the GF pizza and it was delicious! Almost couldn’t believe it was cauliflower. I will definitely be back to try the pasta! The staff was also very friendly, and the server took the allergy very seriously and said they make sure to take the proper precautions for an allergy. My husband and daughter (no allergies) got a Stromboli and calzone and loved them!
• BT

  Brent Tyler

  Feb 21, 2026
  3.0
  Usually everything is right on point however this time the salad I ordered for pick up I found when I got home was not the actual salad I ordered so I was very upset with that other than that they’re fairly good
• PC

  Patricia capozza

  Feb 20, 2026
  1.0
  This was our second time it wasn’t any better. They ran out of spaghetti,the meatballs were terrible, and sauce was acidic. The salad was the only thing we liked.
• BJ

  Brad Johnson

  Feb 12, 2026
  3.0
  We have usually had good service but tonight we waited over 1 hour for our food. 4 tables came in after us but got their food before us. Server said the kitchen lost the order. We got a ‘sorry’ from the server but I would have thought there would have been a discount on our bill. We are disappointed. There are 3 pizza places for us to choose, this won’t be on the list next time!

Frequently Asked Questions About Brooklyn's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant