Brooklyn's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant

Reviews

• CF

  Chuck F

  5 days ago
  2.0
  Came for a authentic NY pizza, got what appeared to be a machine formed, conveyor belt cooked pizza. Got a supreme that had VERY skimpy toppings. On the Dave Portnoy scale a 4.8. Wont be back.
• CC

  Coda Campbell

  5 days ago
  3.0
  We ordered at 5:44pm. We were given an estimated pickup time of 6:19pm. Then an immediate text saying 6:24pm. We got there early and sat at the bar waiting. We were handed the pizzas at 6:43pm, an hour after we ordered and almost 20m after the quoted time. I’d say you need to update your wait time estimation system…
• MH

  Michael Hill

  Apr 23, 2026
  5.0
  This is one of the better pizza joints in the area. We had a large plain pie. It was delicious. I'll be back.
• TE

  Tricia emery

  Apr 17, 2026
  5.0
  We love the pizza! Have only dined in once but pick up often. Forget cheap delivery pizza. Very friendly staff and pizza always ready on time. I believe they offer delivery but we live 5 minutes away. Supreme pizza is the way to go!
• MD

  Mark Dantone

  Mar 25, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered a calzone to go. When I got home, there was no ricotta which is the main ingredient! I called up and spoke to the wife, she insisted that there was plenty of ricotta and she has never had a complaint. So basically calling me a liar! I’m originally from NY and am well aware of how a calzone should be. There was absolutely no ricotta and she didn’t offer an apology or a replacement. So I said ok fine, wasn’t gonna argue as she had her mind made up. Will never go or recommend anyone to that pizzeria ever. Now I make my own calzone at home as no one down here can make one the correct way.

Frequently Asked Questions About Brooklyn's Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant