Jimmy John's

Reviews

• CG

  Chris Guyer

  4 days ago
  1.0
  Paid ~$9 for two pieces of turkey and uncooked bacon. Jersey Mike’s across the street is 1000% better and fresher ✌️
• AH

  Antonio H

  6 days ago
  5.0
  Just passing by and we didn’t realize there’s a Jimmy John’s location at Rinehart Rd. The veggie ram sandwich was really delicious and prepared by the owner that we really appreciated it! We believe that the Jimmy John’s has the same feelings as us Congratulations you are the in the neighborhood!
• GS

  Gabrielle Squillante

  Feb 18, 2026
  5.0
  My fav sandwich shop! Sandwiches are always amazing and the staff are always kind!
• BY

  Brittany Young

  Feb 16, 2026
  5.0
  We showed up late at night. The 2 guys took great care of us. They explained the differences in the Italians they have. Excellent tasting sub!
• RB

  RON BOUGHEY

  Jan 31, 2026
  1.0
  Haven’t been to the Jimmy John’s Lake Mary location before today. I placed the order on the Jimmy John’s website as an in store pick up. I chose 2 sandwiches the Italian Nightclub and the Bootlegger, neither were made as ordered, one actually was the wrong sub entirely. Major major disappointment. I typically order from Jersey Mikes, just wanted to switch it up this time. I would suggest going to Jersey Mikes for a sub. Positive, the bread was really good.