The Diamond Horseshoe

Reviews

• JR

  Jay Ribak

  Apr 25, 2026
  5.0
  The food was a shared family style meal with 3 different meats and lots of different sides. The atmosphere is decent, but plain. The highlight for us though was our server Phillipe from Montreal. 10 out of 10 the best waiter we've ever experienced anywhere.
• AL

  Amber Lee

  Apr 13, 2026
  4.0
  The Diamond Horseshoe sets a good tone for what eating at Disney should be more like. Getting a reservation is difficult and we were lucky to get squeezed in as walk-ins around 5:30. The menu is preset so be aware of that going in, but the menu is pretty kid (and adult) friendly as it’s Thanksgiving themed. The interior is beautiful and it’s a nice, relaxing spot to eat at for a break. Our waiter was very friendly and the food came out pretty quick. As a heads up this is an all you can eat establishment (for around $40-45 bucks a head) so you can eat to your heart’s desire. The meal starts off with their house salad featuring greens, apples, cranberries, and cheese all tossed together. It was surprisingly much better than we thought it would be and if not for maximizing what we ate while there we wouldn’t have minded getting more. Following up the salad is a feast of: roasted turkey, pot roast, pork loin, mashed potatoes, green beans, stuffing, and Mac and cheese. We absolutely dove in. The turkey was alright, not dry (a huge plus) with the pot roast being a much better option in our opinion. The pork loin was delicious with a nice sweet glaze on it. The mac and cheese likewise was good and creamy along with a savory and filling stuffing. The only misses we would say were the mashed potatoes which felt thin and flavorless and then the green beans which really just took up space. For dessert they have their oooey gooey toffee cake which is very sweet but admittedly difficult to put down after the main course. It’s not overly sweet too which is nice to finish your meal on. By the end of our meal we were stuffed and ready to tackle the rest of the night. We would say for the price this might not be the best option for those doing Disney on a budget but if you are a pro at making buffets stretch then this is a decent deal. A solid, filling meal all around and one that is very palette friendly for all.
• JK

  Joshua Kosmerick

  Apr 7, 2026
  1.0
  This restaurant almost ruined our Disney experience. We paid over $200.00 for food that is lower quality than microwave meals.
• CH

  Cameron Hill

  Mar 12, 2026
  5.0
  The food was great. If you can eat a lot, it’s good value. But if you’re visiting with children, you might not get your money’s worth.
• JB

  Jules Biggerstaff

  Mar 8, 2026
  5.0
  Maybe nothing special for atmosphere, BUT we loved the unlimited food and great service! Our first ever Disney experience for family of 5, and day 1 was magic kingdom. Our kids were wiped by 4:30pm and this was the only “reservation” we could get last minute as an early sit down dinner. We were able to get a much needed a cold beer for us parents and we loved the food for being actually fairly healthy and hearty. Excellent service, I would definitely do this again if we visit DW again!

Frequently Asked Questions About The Diamond Horseshoe