Service experiences varied significantly; while some servers received high praise for attentiveness and friendliness, others were criticized for being rude or inattentive.
Food Quality
Food quality was inconsistent, with some dishes praised for their taste and portion sizes, while others were described as bland, overcooked, or lacking flavor.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was generally well-received, noted for its cozy, beachy vibe, although noise levels were sometimes a concern.
Staff Recognition
Several reviews highlighted specific staff members, particularly Tyrone and Tess, for their exceptional service, contributing positively to the dining experience.
Overall Experience
While many customers enjoyed their meals and the overall experience, there were notable complaints about food quality and service consistency, leading to mixed reviews.
BW
Blue Water67
Feb 25, 2026
5.0
Had a great brunch at Olivia 's restaurant in Old Key West Resort. Great food and service!
BS
Brae Swift
Feb 25, 2026
5.0
Such a cute spot to grab breakfast before heading into the park!!
DH
David Scott Heier
Feb 16, 2026
2.0
I can only report my own personal experience, which may deviate from others. My wife and I took our kids and grandkids for a late brunch. My wife I both ordered the salmon salad. All the dishes were served except one of the salmon salads so I waited for the missing one while everyone else began eating. It took at least another 5 minutes for mine to appear. When I started eating I discovered that the rather thin slice of salmon was a red rare on the skin side. It was not edible and had to be sent back. When my meal was finally served, every one else had finished theirs. The latest salmon was way overcooked and dry. I did not complain because the young grandkids were ready to go and I had not started my meal. For $150 I expected a far better experience.
MM
manny martinez
Feb 8, 2026
5.0
Banana bread French toast.... incase there was some confusion...Banana bread french toast 🥰
BB
Bayley Bodien
Jan 27, 2026
1.0
The food was ok but the service was even worse. We had a party of 6 including 2 kids (5 and 11 months). Our server was clearly annnoyed from the beginning. When ordering I asked if I could order a side of mashed potatoes for our 11month old. She stated no that they don’t do special orders. I said well mashed potatoes are on the menu and served with the chicken dinner. She just blankly stared at me. So my husband ordered the chicken just so we could have masked potatoes for her. She came to check on us once and never came to refill drinks or even offer. I have never ever had bad service at a Disney restaurant, infact I usually rave about how awesome it is but this was TERRIBLE service and I won’t ever eat there again.
Olivia's Cafe serves hearty home cooking with a taste of the Florida Keys, focusing on American cuisine.
What are the opening hours of Olivia's Cafe?
Olivia's Cafe is open daily from 7:30 AM to 2:00 PM and then from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM.
Does Olivia's Cafe accept reservations?
Yes, Olivia's Cafe accepts reservations to help you plan your visit.
Is Olivia's Cafe wheelchair accessible?
Yes, Olivia's Cafe features wheelchair accessible entrances, seating, parking, and restrooms.
Can I find vegetarian and vegan options at Olivia's Cafe?
Yes, Olivia's Cafe offers vegetarian and vegan options as part of their menu.
Does Olivia's Cafe serve alcoholic beverages?
Yes, Olivia's Cafe serves alcohol including beer, wine, and cocktails.
Where is Olivia's Cafe located?
Olivia's Cafe is located at 1510 North Cove Road, Disney's Old Key West Resort, Lake Buena Vista, FL 32830, USA.
What nearby attractions can I visit before or after dining at Olivia's Cafe?
You can visit Disney's Old Key West Resort, Millers Road Pool, or the Sandcastle Pool, all located near Olivia's Cafe for a full day of fun and relaxation.
Are there convenient transportation options near Olivia's Cafe?
Yes, nearby transportation options include the Hospitality House Bus Stop, Old Key West Peninsular Road Bus Stop, and Disney's Magical Express bus station, making it easy to reach Olivia's Cafe.
Where can I find amenities such as ATMs near Olivia's Cafe?
You can find Chase ATMs near Olivia's Cafe for your banking needs during your visit.
Brand Certified Facts from Olivia's Cafe
This information is certified by Olivia's Cafe and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: