Cape May Cafe

Reviews

• LS

  Lisa Spiering

  3 days ago
  2.0
  We made a reservation for 9:30 and we’re not seated until 10:09. The reservation was made for 7, they said there was an issue at check in and they didn’t seat us until 40 minutes after our reservation.
• SS

  STEVE

  Feb 19, 2026
  5.0
  Great buffet. Paella was great this time. BBQ Ribs, shrimp, chicken, salads were also good. Kids have many choices too! Pizza, chicken nuggets, mac and cheese. And don't forget desert, cherry cheesecake, mini-cream puffs, chocolate tarts, strawberry cake and more.
• AS

  Ashley Sullivan

  Feb 17, 2026
  5.0
  What a pleasant experience! Such a cute vibe at the Beach Club! We had to wait a bit for a table even with a reservation but the staff was very friendly and kept us engaged. We did breakfast (buffet style) , our server was a bit slow and overwhelmed (forgot syrup, no refills) but it didn't take away much from the experience! So fun to see the characters in beach wear and walk along the boardwalk. Worth the visit!
• HW

  Heidi Whitley

  Feb 13, 2026
  5.0
  We went for the character breakfast. Wonderful experience! Go to see Donald Daisy , Minnie & Goofy! Loved the buffet option. The kids got to pick out their own food. Food was good. The bacon was cooked perfectly. Kids were happy and that’s all that matters. Huge thank you to Donald Duck for visiting our table twice (my son’s favorite character).
• MT

  McCarthy Terri

  Feb 7, 2026
  4.0
  I can't believe we paid $50 for a buffet. I definitely did not eat $50 worth of food, however, some in the party could with all the seafood they ate. I wasn't aware beverages were included, so I didn't order coffee. I wish our server would have told us this. There are many options to please everyone's food desires. The desserts were my favorite and all were excellent. The place was very crowded and noisy though.