Creating SWEET memories since 1973, our handmade candies and homemade ice cream are made fresh daily in front of our guests for a unique and delicious experience served with good, old-fashioned hospitality.
Many customers found the prices to be excessively high for the quality and quantity of the products offered.
Product Quality
While some items like pralines and ice cream received positive feedback, others such as taffy and rice crispy treats were criticized for poor taste and texture.
Customer Service
The staff was frequently described as friendly and helpful, although there were some reports of poor service experiences.
Variety
Customers appreciated the wide selection of sweets, including candies, chocolates, and ice cream, making it a fun place to explore.
Atmosphere
The shop's nostalgic charm and inviting atmosphere were highlighted positively by many reviewers.
CK
Crystal King
Oct 26, 2025
5.0
Loved River Street sweets ! Great vibe and great Sweets !! William definitely be back !
SS
Stephanie
Oct 26, 2025
1.0
overpriced nothing special
LB
lindsay brown
Oct 13, 2025
1.0
Tasted good but $43 for two rice krispy treats and 1 marshmallow kind of ruined the taste👎
WK
William Kallemeyn
Oct 3, 2025
1.0
Very expensive to get a bag and choose candy, it was over $30 for us and we didn’t get that much. The taffy was gross, super soft and sticky even after putting them in a fridge overnight. Some of the wrappers were not closed up all of the way, and most of them were sticky on the outside. I don’t recommend getting candy there, maybe their ice cream is better.
SR
Shirah Rodriguez
Aug 25, 2025
4.0
Very expensive desserts but worth at least trying 1 thing if you’re a sweets fan, like me! They have so many different peanut butter cups,pretzels, candy and ice creams!
Frequently Asked Questions About River Street Sweets
What types of sweets and treats does River Street Sweets offer?
River Street Sweets offers handmade chocolates like Bear Claws®, World Famous Pralines®, gourmet caramel apples, and homemade ice cream made fresh daily.
Where is River Street Sweets located?
It is located at 400 Duval St B, Key West, Florida, 33040, USA.
What are the operating hours of River Street Sweets?
River Street Sweets is open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Does River Street Sweets offer delivery or in-store pickup options?
Yes, River Street Sweets offers both delivery, including same-day delivery, and in-store pickup options.
Which payment methods are accepted at River Street Sweets?
They accept credit cards, debit cards, and mobile NFC payments. They do not require cash only and do not accept checks.
How can I contact River Street Sweets for more information?
You can call their main phone at +1 305-922-2144 or email keywest@riverstreetsweets.com.
Is River Street Sweets active on social media?
Yes, River Street Sweets is active on Facebook, Instagram (@riverstreetsweets), TikTok, and YouTube.
What nearby dining options are available to visit before or after River Street Sweets?
Nearby dining includes The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. for American and seafood cuisine, Kojin Noodle Bar for Japanese and Asian dishes, and Glazed Donuts for bakery treats and coffee.
What nearby shopping and art galleries can visitors explore around River Street Sweets?
Visitors can explore LIK Fine Art and Peter Lik Key West art galleries as well as boutique stores like Fresh Produce in Key West and Claire's for fashion accessories.
Are there notable nearby hotels or resorts for visitors to stay close to River Street Sweets?
Yes, nearby accommodations include Ocean Key Resort & Spa and Inn Touch In Key West, both located close to River Street Sweets.