Creating SWEET memories since 1973, our handmade candies and homemade ice cream are made fresh daily in front of our guests for a unique and delicious experience served with good, old-fashioned hospitality.
Many customers found the prices to be excessively high for the quality of the treats offered.
Quality
While some customers praised the quality of certain items like pralines and ice cream, others reported disappointment with the taste and quality of various sweets.
Customer Service
The staff received mixed reviews; some customers highlighted friendly and helpful service, while others experienced dismissive or unhelpful interactions.
Variety
The shop offers a wide selection of sweets, including chocolates, ice cream, and unique treats, which many customers appreciated.
LL
Lynn
Feb 14, 2026
2.0
I really wanted to like this place, as it was my first time trying their treats. First off, the employees were kind, especially the young man that helped me where the fudge amd candy apples are kept, he was really nice. The shop is clean and I love the sweet shop concept. However, the cost is very expensive for what you are getting and the taste of these treats, are not great at all. I ordered 1 regular rice Krispy treat and 2 small pecan pralines, which came out to $16.43, and this was with a discount. The rice Krispy treat and pralines tastes cheap, like they are made with palm oil and not real butter, no vanilla, just bland, my daughter spit the Krispy out! What child spits out a rice Krispy?! If you are going to charge so much, please use better quality ingredients.
DM
Dalton Morris
Jan 31, 2026
3.0
Very expensive, but the quality is better than other places. You can tell they use better ingredients. The peanut butter cups I got are kind of mediocre, but still good. The real winner for us was the fruity pebbles rice krispie treat. It's huge, and so delicious!
I give it 3/5 because the prices just seem way too high. I would probably avoid going here again just because of that.
BH
Barbara Heron
Jan 12, 2026
5.0
River Street Sweets is a mouthwatering experience of soe of the best chocolates I've ever had. The milk and dark chocolate pralines were incredible as well as the super large peanut butter cup. I visited a shop in Key West and left with a few tasty treats. Luckily, River Street has a website. I'm about to place an order.
TB
Tom Blomberg
Jan 10, 2026
1.0
A bored, young, unpleasant ice cream vendor.
CC
Carsten
Jan 10, 2026
3.0
10$ für eine Kugel Eis.
Das Eis war gut, aber es war nicht der Hammer.
Kann ich mir nicht erklären. Keinerlei Argumentation.
Selbst für Key West Verhältnisse sehr überteuert.
Frequently Asked Questions About River Street Sweets
What types of sweets and treats does River Street Sweets offer?
River Street Sweets offers handmade chocolates like Bear Claws®, World Famous Pralines®, gourmet caramel apples, and homemade ice cream made fresh daily.
Where is River Street Sweets located?
It is located at 400 Duval St B, Key West, Florida, 33040, USA.
What are the operating hours of River Street Sweets?
River Street Sweets is open daily from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM.
Does River Street Sweets offer delivery or in-store pickup options?
Yes, River Street Sweets offers both delivery, including same-day delivery, and in-store pickup options.
Which payment methods are accepted at River Street Sweets?
They accept credit cards, debit cards, and mobile NFC payments. They do not require cash only and do not accept checks.
How can I contact River Street Sweets for more information?
You can call their main phone at +1 305-922-2144 or email keywest@riverstreetsweets.com.
Is River Street Sweets active on social media?
Yes, River Street Sweets is active on Facebook, Instagram (@riverstreetsweets), TikTok, and YouTube.
What nearby dining options are available to visit before or after River Street Sweets?
Nearby dining includes The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. for American and seafood cuisine, Kojin Noodle Bar for Japanese and Asian dishes, and Glazed Donuts for bakery treats and coffee.
What nearby shopping and art galleries can visitors explore around River Street Sweets?
Visitors can explore LIK Fine Art and Peter Lik Key West art galleries as well as boutique stores like Fresh Produce in Key West and Claire's for fashion accessories.
Are there notable nearby hotels or resorts for visitors to stay close to River Street Sweets?
Yes, nearby accommodations include Ocean Key Resort & Spa and Inn Touch In Key West, both located close to River Street Sweets.
Brand Certified Facts from River Street Sweets
This information is certified by River Street Sweets and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: