Mrs. Mac's Kitchen (Big)

Reviews

• BS

  Bridget Spencer

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Love this place! Highly recommend it as a first timer. We were met with a cheerful hello and promptly seated. It waitress was friendly and attentive. Had the bacon, blue cheese burger and it was delicious! Came with thin cut, delicious cottage fries and were perfectly fried in fresh tasting oil. Topped off our lunch with a slice of delicious key lime pie. There are tons of options on the menu to serve anyone's taste.
• HL

  Haim L

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Don't bother trying any other key lime pie. I wasn't expecting much when I ordered. Alot of people tend to exaggerate. I thought it was going to be like Guinness is for the Irish. Every Irishmen will tell you their pub serves the best Guinness. The others either don't use the KL zest or just use artificial lemon/lime juice. Their pie is beat welhen served frozen. Their custard is smooth, velvety and like ice cream when frozen.
• RW

  Robert Wagoner

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Excellent diner. The Bahama Burger was cooked to perfection with the thickest slice of bacon you've ever seen. Huge scoop of avocado with sour cream and mayo along with all the veggies. The coleslaw, homemade, it's also very delicious. Not too sweet not too tart just right. My wife had the conch chowder and said it was excellent but not a lot of conch in it. At the top it off we tried the peanut butter pie. Excellent. Enjoyed our stop.
• JV

  John Vince

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Came here specifically for the key lime pie, and it did not disappoint! Honestly the best we had in the Keys. Perfect balance of tart and sweet with that classic, smooth texture you hope for but rarely get. Lunch was really good across the board (recommend the mahi fish tacos), and the service was fantastic. Friendly, attentive, and genuinely on point the whole time. If key lime pie is on your agenda, this one should be at the top of your list!
• KB

  Kelsey Brandenburg

  Apr 12, 2026
  5.0
  My family and I enjoyed dining here during our recent trip to Key Largo! The food was excellent — we got the fish of the day, grouper tacos, a kids meal (which came with ice cream!) and key lime pie. We enjoyed all of it, everything was fresh and delicious. The staff were also so friendly and accommodating! I believe a young lady named Mary took care of us and she was great!

Frequently Asked Questions About Mrs. Mac's Kitchen (Big)