Pie95 Pizza

Reviews

• MA

  Marwan A

  3 days ago
  5.0
  My wife and I have been here twice and we love it. This is easily my favorite pizza spot and one of the best in Jacksonville especially for authentic wood-fired pizza. It really reminds me of the pizza I had in Italy. We got the Pizza Du Jour (no pepperoni since we don’t eat pork) and The Romantica both were amazing. Honestly, everything we’ve tried on the menu has been great you really can’t go wrong with anything. And the tiramisu is a MUST try… sooo good. We’ll definitely keep coming back.
• MA

  Mary Anderson

  5 days ago
  5.0
  This place is amazing. After living in NYC I've struggled to find good pizza in Jacksonville. Pie95 is absolutely fantastic, and I don't go anywhere else these days! Plus Evan and the crew are so kind and welcoming. Great atmosphere, absolutely delicious, and reasonable. I recommend to all :)
• TC

  Tessa Cook

  Apr 12, 2026
  5.0
  Hands-down, one of my favorite pizza places I’ve ever been to! I’ve lived in several cities and states and tried pizza across different regions! This is one of my go to spots whenever I have friends or family visit. The owner takes great care in the experience of the customer and ensures that every pizza comes out consistently the way it is intended. Not only that, because the owner is a train chef, he creates delicious specials that are elevated beyond just a pizza joint! I love that there aren’t 1000 things on the menu that can make restaurants feel overwhelming. The concept is straightforward and delicious which is all you could ask for from a pizza place.
• BL

  Bryan Lakey

  Apr 12, 2026
  5.0
  My wife & I have been regulars here since Pie95 opened. They are, hands down, the best Neapolitan pizza in Northeast Florida. Evan brings a fine dining background to the kitchen & his team are making pizza at an elite level. The staff is excellent & always super friendly. We love their meatballs, and shrimp appetizer... the arugula salad is a must - everything is phenomenal. For the pizza, you really can't go wrong with the Carnivore or Fungi Pizza... we always look forward to trying their weekly specials. Also, do not sleep on the tiramisu. It is the best in town, bar none. Five stars all the way
• SB

  S B

  Apr 12, 2026
  5.0
  I really love Pie95! The folks who work here are super nice and giving and I love all their pizzas. It really made me smile a month ago when I went in to order a pizza and was asked to try a fresh baked pizza and give my opinions. It was delightful and I was so appreciative because I was starving! Thank you Pie95 for being such an awesome neighborhood gem and for feeding me and my family :)

Frequently Asked Questions About Pie95 Pizza