Goodfellas Pizza Jacksonville

Reviews

• DA

  Deleted Account

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Eve took our order and she was awesome. Their register had a malfunction and I was double charged, but the manager immediately came over to resolve the issue. They also had a pretty hectic rush during my visit but everyone worked together very peacefully and quickly…. (Which is rare to see in a hot and busy kitchen). It was very cool to see the open kitchen and watch how professional and clean the staff handled the food. Overall, great experience, affordable prices and great food. Definitely my new “go-to” pizza spot.
• TD

  Trina Don

  Nov 13, 2025
  1.0
  This is a terrible experience. Think you get online and you order you food. You pay for you food you get a time to pick your food up. You get someone to cover your classroom so you can pick up your lunch. Then you get there on time and they say about 10 min before it’s going to be done. The. Imagine after asking for a refund because you don’t have the time to wait and being told very rudely that you should have just waited for for your food. Then imagine when you get back to work you get a verbal warning about being late for lunch. And you still don’t have food to eat and you’re going to have to wait for your money back. That right there is excellence in service. I would rather eat mediocre food that’s prepared on time. Imagine it’s not the first time having to wait.
• CC

  Childcare Conversations

  Nov 10, 2025
  5.0
  My family and I are always on the hunt for a great late-night snack, and Good Fellas absolutely delivered. From the moment we walked in, we were greeted warmly and treated like regulars. The jerk pizza was bold and delicious, the cheese pizza was so cheesy and fresh. The wings OMG! I tried four different flavors and each one was cooked to perfection. They truly exceeded my expectations. Now my kids are hooked and asking for Good Fellas 2–3 times a week. Great food, great vibes, and open late. I can only say try them for yourself you will not be disappointed.
• DM

  Dwayne Mitchell

  Nov 10, 2025
  5.0
  This pizza is by far the best in the city!!! But it’s not just the pizza the wings are great as well! Cooked well to perfection with a variety of sauces! The restaurant is clean and the customer service is excellent! I definitely recommend Goodfellas and will be going back!!!
• CC

  Ceciley Crowley

  Nov 4, 2025
  3.0
  The best pizza I’ve had in over a decade!!The staff seemed brand new to the food service industry or like they’ve been traumatized by customer interactions. I was calling on the drive there but no answer. When I arrived I inquired and a young lady told me they were busy and didn’t answer. Obviously untrue. The gentleman and possibly manager or owner told me it’s best to place an online order and it’ll be ready when I arrive. That was clearly the truth and a more sensible response. Truth goes further than just blowing smoke and now I know how to place an order in advance. My only real critique is that they need to invest in hair nets or some type of hair covering because it’s only a matter of time before hair gets in the food. If they get hair nets they’ll have a customer for life.

Frequently Asked Questions About Goodfellas Pizza Jacksonville