Business Details
About
RestaurantBar & GrillSeafood Restaurant
Safari Lounge, which had been affectionally nicknamed “The Dead Animal Bar” by Islamorada locals, was a beloved Lower Matecumbe landmark for decades.
Now let’s fast-forward to today and: Breaking News!!!
Suntex Marinas came to the rescue with that much-needed TLC in the form of major renovations to the building; inside and out, throughout the property, everything from a brand-spanking new full kitchen with all new equipment, to a new and beautifully-landscaped private beachside lounge.
Guests will once again be able to enjoy delicious food & cool drink, both indoors and outdoors, all served up in casual comfortable classic Keys style. Oh, almost forgot, every cocktail comes with a spectacular ocean view!
Location
Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge (Permanently Closed)
73814 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL
33036, United States
Hours
Reviews
4.4
228 reviews
5 stars
164
4 stars
30
3 stars
15
2 stars
6
1 star
13
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Overall, customers enjoyed the food, highlighting dishes like fish tacos, shrimp, and key lime pie, though some found it overpriced or inconsistent.
Service
Service received mixed reviews; many praised specific staff members for their friendliness and attentiveness, while others noted issues with slow service and understaffing.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's location and views were frequently praised, creating a pleasant dining experience, although some felt the decor lacked a true 'Keys' vibe.
Management Issues
Several reviews mentioned poor management and operational challenges, including reservation issues and staff shortages, impacting the overall experience.
Value for Money
Some customers felt the prices were high for the quality of food and service received, suggesting a need for better alignment between cost and experience.
- MRMayte ReyesMay 6, 20235.0The restaurant popped up on my social media, and we el decided to give it a try. To our surprise Frannie greeted us at the door with the best attitude and so welcoming! Frannie’s service is beyond excellent!! ! Thank you Frannie! The food is great and the drinks on point, thanks to Frannie!
- JEJamie Engel, Florida Keys Real EstateApr 14, 20234.0Formerly known as the DAB (Dead Animal Bar) 😂 this locals spot has been purchased and completely remodeled. The atmosphere is certainly not what it was previously, but the ocean views will never go away. We tried the chef special the day we were there, which were salmon, fish, tacos. I will say they were delicious! I know I know I know were in the keys but I just couldn’t resist. Trying the salmon. Very happy I did. Our server was friendly and attentive. The prices were , very reasonable. I would recommend you stop bye and try it for yourself whether you’re headed south to key west or north going home to Miami. Located at mile marker 73 on the ocean side.
- ADAdiela DiazApr 5, 20235.0If you are looking for a place to eat, drink and have a good time come to Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge. Best bartender to come see is Francois! Very attentive, talkative, hospitable and mixes the best drinks you will ever have. Shout out also to Shane (Restaurant Manager) made me feel welcomed, he was very attentive to all the guest that came in. made sure that every person that came in was receiving excellent customer service and happy with their orders. (All staff working at Safari makes the restaurant/lounge warm and inviting). It's definitely a place to come back to. :-)
- VBVinny BeardSep 23, 20145.0I played there on their Tuesday Night JAM Open Mic 3 weeks ago and Liked the Fun and People so much I came back the following week. Tonight I will be Bringing my Amp to Play and provide for other Bass Guitarists That I have invited. Why? Simply because, They are a Great bunch of people and take very good care of Everybody Musicians Audience and the Simple pleasure of Nostalgia. And Patty is a Doll behind this Traditional Island Bar and I just love her and support her all the way. I am Retired here in the Florida Keys 7 years from NYC and I am having a Ball at this place and a few Like it here. Come and Listen Eat Drink and Meet a true Landmark and Fun place to be! Don't let this Rainy stuff stop you. And don't think I am easily impressed. I was a stranger made to feel like I was born around the corner!
Frequently Asked Questions About Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge (Permanently Closed)
Is the Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge currently open?
The Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge is permanently closed and not operating.
Where was the Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge located?
It was located at 73814 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, USA.
What type of food and atmosphere did Oceanside Safari offer before closing?
It was a seafood restaurant and bar & grill serving delicious food and cool drinks in a casual, comfortable classic Keys style with ocean views.
Are there any amenities associated with the former Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge?
The venue featured a brand new full kitchen and a beautifully landscaped private beachside lounge to enjoy meals and cocktails with ocean views.
What is the phone number to contact Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge?
The main phone number was +1 305-390-4572, but since the restaurant is permanently closed, it may no longer be operational.
Can I view the menu or learn more about Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge online?
Information and menu were available on their website at https://oceansidesafari.com/, but please note the restaurant is permanently closed.
What nearby fishing charters are available around the former location of Oceanside Safari?
Nearby fishing charters include Pelagic Color Fishing Company, Best Day Ever Charters, and Reel Attack Charters enabling visitors to enjoy local fishing experiences.
Are there beaches close to the former Oceanside Safari Restaurant & Lounge for visitors to enjoy?
Yes, nearby beaches include Anne’s Beach, Sunset Beach Islamorada, Michaels Beach, Dog Beach, and White Marlin Beach, great for relaxing before or after dining in the area.
What nearby marinas or boating services can visitors use in the Islamorada area?
Nearby marinas are Caloosa Cove Marina and Boater's World Marine Centers; these offer boating and marine supplies services for visitors exploring the waters.
What nearby accommodation options are available near the former Oceanside Safari location?
Caloosa Cove Resort is a nearby hotel and resort option for visitors looking to stay close to the former restaurant location.