Islamorada Fish Company

Reviews

• YA

  YAIREN ALVAREZ

  Nov 14, 2025
  5.0
  I had my wedding here in Islamorada this past Sunday, and it was an absolute dream come true. From start to finish, everything was perfect. A huge thank-you to Jill and Lexie — their professionalism, support, and attention to detail made the entire experience unforgettable. The food was excellent, the service was flawless, and the entire team went above and beyond to make our day special. I 100% recommend this venue to anyone looking for a beautiful setting and a highly professional staff. Truly an incredible place to get married!
• EK

  Emily Keys

  Nov 13, 2025
  5.0
  We had the most incredible experience at this wedding venue! From start to finish, everything was seamless, beautiful, and beyond what we imagined for our big day. The staff, Marissa, Jill and Lexi were so attentive and genuinely invested in making sure every detail was perfect. One thing we’re STILL getting compliments on is the food. It was absolutely phenomenal—fresh, flavorful, and beautifully presented. Our guests kept telling us it was the best wedding meal they’ve ever had, and we couldn’t agree more. The atmosphere, the service, and the cuisine all came together to create a day we’ll never forget. Highly recommend this venue to any couple looking for a stunning setting and exceptional dining!
• EE

  Emily Engelke

  Nov 8, 2025
  4.0
  Service was great (though the server was a bit crabby) and it was beautiful sitting by the water with live mesic. The food is underwhelming and expensive however. We ordered the smoked fish dip which tastes like any other fish dip we’ve ever had, the conch chowder didn’t have much conch in it and was Manhattan-style with what tasted like Bloody Mary mix. Then we also tried the conch fritters which were so much breading and way over seasoned. Great for a visit and appetizers split between people and have drinks while enjoying the atmosphere.
• KF

  Kenna Fallacaro

  Nov 6, 2025
  5.0
  I don’t even know where to begin because there truly aren’t enough words to express how perfect our wedding day was at Islamorada Fish Company. From the very first conversation to the end of the night, everything exceeded anything I could have dreamed of. It was the kind of day you replay in your head forever. Working with Jill and Marissa was one of the biggest blessings of this entire process. They were not only organized, professional, and communicative — they were kind, patient, and genuinely invested in making our day magical. Every question was answered, every detail was handled, and they somehow made everything feel effortless, even when I was a stressed-out bride trying to make a thousand decisions. I truly felt supported every step of the way. The venue itself? Absolutely breathtaking. The views, the atmosphere, the tropical breeze, the golden sunset — it felt like every moment was taken straight out of a magazine. The décor came together more beautifully than I could have imagined. What I pictured in my head, they brought to life in reality — and even better. My whole family was blown away. Everyone kept saying how stunning it was, how relaxed the vibe felt, and how “us” the whole evening was. One of the biggest gifts this venue gave me was peace of mind. Weddings come with so many moving parts, emotions, and expectations — but here, I didn’t feel stress. I got to just be the bride. I was able to actually enjoy the moment, be present, laugh with my family, feel the love, and soak in every second. That alone is priceless. The food was incredible, the service was amazing, and the flow of the night was seamless. Every member of the staff was warm and attentive, and so many guests told us it was not only one of the most beautiful weddings they’d ever attended, but one of the most enjoyable. Islamorada Fish Company gave us more than a venue — they gave us memories we’ll cherish forever. If you’re considering getting married in the Keys… stop searching. This is the place. I would choose it a thousand times again. With so much gratitude, A very happy bride 💍✨
• JH

  Jeremiah Haidon

  Nov 4, 2025
  5.0
  We had an absolutely amazing wedding here. Jill was a dream to work with as the wedding/ events manager! Her calmness and expertise lowered our anxiety through the whole wedding process. Jill and her staff can create a dream wedding with little to no time! As weddings budgets can blow out of proportion, Jill helped keep us on budget all while creating a stunning venue that created lasting memories for all who attended! Thank you Jill, Lexi, Marissa, Brandon and Islamorada Fish Co staff for an amazing wedding!

Frequently Asked Questions About Islamorada Fish Company