Pizza by the Sea at Seacrest Beach

Reviews

• CH

  Charles Michael Hinkle

  5 days ago
  4.0
  This is where my Gluten/Dairy/Egg Pescatarian DAUGHTER CAN EAT! She loved it and the food was excellent with NO FOOD ALLERGY GUILT! Thank you to the understanding staff❤️
• AF

  Amanda Fritts

  6 days ago
  5.0
  We did takeout one night, walkable from our house in Seacrest, and thoroughly enjoyed our pizzas! Everyone, including two toddlers, raved about it. Pizzas were ready quickly and stayed hot on the walk back! Will definitely be back on our next trip to 30A.
• ET

  Elle Turner

  Apr 6, 2026
  3.0
  Update: The manager contacted me to apologize and offered a full refund. We booked a sunset bonfire on the beach for my sister’s bachelorette party, and the significant wait times at Pizza by the Sea ruined it. Our 3-hour bonfire was intended to start at 6:30 for a 7:06 sunset. When we were placing the order for our pizza at 5:43 (after continually reloading the wait time from 5pm on to ensure we didn’t order too early so as to have cold pizza), it said it would be ready at 6:15. As soon as we placed the order, the estimate changed to 6:28, which was very annoying, but we tried to roll with it. We arrived for order pickup early and explained it was a special night, which the staff could not have cared less about. They told us to wait for a text to indicate our order was ready. At 6:28, we went inside again and they said 15 more minutes. At this point, we were a 10 minute uber away from the bonfire so we figured, okay, we’ll still get there in time to take a couple pictures before sunset, whatever. At 6:43, we went inside, and they said 20 more minutes. We didn’t get the pizza until well after sunset and missed over an hour of our sunset bonfire. We also never got a text indicating the pizza was ready, so I’m not sure why they kept saying that. The staff was very rude every time we talked to them. The restaurant was filled with smoke, so we had to wait outside in the sun. We also had to tip in advance when placing the order, and they didn’t even refund the 25% tip after all of this - which is kind of insane given it was a pickup order that was delayed an hour. I would not recommend this location for any special events, but if you don’t care about your time or anyone else’s, the pizza is pizza.
• SP

  Sameer Patel

  Apr 4, 2026
  5.0
  Came for the pizza, stayed for Mathew’s absolute main character energy. The pizza was legit — hot, cheesy, and hit the spot. But Mathew? Mathew was out here running the place like a motivational speaker in a pizza shop. Kid had more energy than three Red Bulls and a playoff game. Give that kid a raise… or at least unlimited breadsticks. 10/10 vibes, 10/10 pizza. Will definitely be back.
• SE

  Susan Evans

  Mar 31, 2026
  5.0
  A pizza and salad were amazing. Especially loved the crust of the pizza. The hot honey pepperoni was our favorite. Ordering online was easy and I received lots of communications about our order.

Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza by the Sea at Seacrest Beach