Main St Pizza & Ice Cream

Reviews

• ES

  Emma Sledge

  1 day ago
  5.0
  We came in with a larger group, service was excellent! It was easily the best pizza I’ve ever had! I had the bruschetta pizza and it was AMAZING! I’d highly recommend stopping by on your next outing!
• KC

  Kip Calhoun

  5 days ago
  5.0
  I had my company retirement party here and Matt who is the owner along with his staff did an amazing job. The service was excellent, the food was delicious and they were so friendly. We had at least around 20 people. I would recommend you go and see for yourself. We will definitely be going back again!!!
• GA

  Gary Aube

  Apr 23, 2026
  1.0
  We went a few weeks ago and had the greatest pizza. The crust was prefect and it was not dry. On the second time it was so different, the pizza was so dry plus burned. It was suppose to have extra cheese, their was none. The toppings were very thin with little sauce. My wife's pizza, she said it was very bland and taste-less and dry. They will never see us again!
• AS

  Andres Sabogal

  Apr 18, 2026
  1.0
  The food was good, which makes this even more disappointing. Unfortunately, the service was consistently poor. I understand it’s a self-service outdoor setup, but when they brought the food out to the tables, the attitude was terrible and it felt like you shouldn’t ask for anything. The server, who is the same person taking orders, had a terrible attitude. We even asked for forks and the server basically just threw them on the table. We had a conversation with nearby tables who shared the same terrible experience. We also asked to speak with a manager, but there was no manager on site on a Saturday, which was surprising. Additionally, the order window was closed most of the time, and several people were waiting and asking for someone to take their order. They also didn’t have ice available and were unable to serve beer or alcoholic beverages at the time. Overall, the experience didn’t match the quality of the food. I hope they improve their service because the potential is there.
• CO

  Carter Oakley

  Apr 14, 2026
  3.0
  I eat here all the time and the food is consistently great. Definitely one of my go-to spots around Hastings. The issue is ordering later in the evening. They’re listed as open until 9, but if you call around 8, most of the time no one answers and it just rings. On the rare occasion someone does pick up, you’re told the “oven is broke.” After dealing with this a few times, it seems like takeout and delivery actually cut off around 8:15. That’s fine if that’s the policy, but it’s frustrating that it’s not clearly communicated and instead comes across like they just stop answering calls or give different reasons like “the oven is broken.” If there’s a cutoff time for orders, it would be much better to be upfront about it or adjust the posted hours so customers know what to expect, instead of burying it in a hidden drop-down menu. Because of this, if we’re trying to get pizza around 8, we usually end up going across the street to Domino’s instead. Great food overall, just wish the service and communication matched it all the way up to closing.