Island Burger and Shake

Reviews

• SA

  Shelley Anderson

  Jan 5, 2026
  5.0
  If you love a good Smash burger, this is the place. I have yet to have a better smash burger anywhere else. And for those who complained about the burgers being thin and crispy- that is the definition of a smash burger- which means this restaurant served what their menu said they were going to serve and they did an amazing job with it. We travel from PSL to have these burgers, passing hundreds of burger places on the way.
• HC

  Heather Copeland

  Jan 3, 2026
  4.0
  We visited yesterday, for the first time. It was right around lunch time and only 1 table outside was taken. We ended up sitting inside because all of the condiments and napkins etc we swarming with fruit fly type bugs. Normal? Yes. But we just didnt want to deal with that while trying to eat. The inside was clean and nice. We were greeted immediately and told to sit anywhere. Drink orders were taken quickly. Simple menu, which I appreciate!! We both got the Double D burgers 🍔 with everything. Very tasty! We also got a "regular " fry and the "kitchen sink" fries. Both were very good. The pickles tasted pretty sweet, which a hate, but the blended well with the burger and fry toppings so it wasn't too bad. We got shakes to go. Chocolate with chocolate drizzle and vanilla with Oreo crumbles. Both were DELICIOUS 😋! Despite being almost empty, service was slow. We couldn't get drink refills and ended up getting them ourselves. The pricing seems fair, until you add extras. For 2 burger meals, 2 sodas, 2 shakes, (auto) 18% gratuity, tax, and tip it was 75! That seems quite steep for burgers and shakes. Other than pricing, this place was great! I'd definitely go back
• SS

  Sami Smidi

  Dec 28, 2025
  5.0
  Among food awesome vibes and the crew is super fun. Smash burger on point truffle fries were so good. Executive chef was so involved and attentive. I would drive from Deerfield beach just to eat here and chill. And parking is free as of dec 2025
• JB

  Jerline B.

  Dec 23, 2025
  2.0
  I really wanted to like this place, and I’m trying to keep this review positive because I truly believe that with the right team and consistency, it could be much better. Unfortunately, our experience fell short. We ordered four burgers, and one of them was made incorrectly four separate times. In the end, the manager comped that one burger, which was appreciated, but it didn’t really help since it still wasn’t what we ordered and honestly wasn’t very good. The meat was overcooked, the patty was very thin, and overall the burger lacked flavor. I ordered fries with bacon and cheese. The bacon itself was thick, but the fries were cold and the cheese was missing entirely. Service was also an issue — my drink was forgotten, and no utensils were brought to the table. My son had to get up himself just to grab a straw. After spending about $150 on the meal (4 burgers, special order of fries, and 3 milkshakes), the level of service and food quality was disappointing. Given how the night went, it honestly would have made more sense for the entire meal to be comped rather than just one incorrect burger. The highlight of the visit was the churro milkshake — it was genuinely good. If I ever came back, it would honestly be just for that. We decided to try this spot because a well-known food reviewer “Baldy Eats” hyped it up as having some of the best smash burgers around, but that wasn’t even close to our experience. At the price point, the quality just didn’t match the cost. Overall, we won’t be returning. I hope the owner and kitchen staff refocus on why the restaurant was opened in the first place — quality, consistency, and care — because right now it feels more like an expensive burger with low execution rather than a standout smash burger spot.
• JS

  Joey Joe Joe Jr Shabadoo

  Dec 16, 2025
  5.0
  First time here, sat at the bar and the smash burger was like whoa, this burger is phenomenal. Crisp edges on the patties like a smash burger needs to be, delicious sauce, fresh bun and truffle oil fries were crispy and salty. Paired with a mango wheat ale beer satisfied my cravings for salt, sweet and meat. Fun vibes with cool dead head swag on the walls and the wait staff was attentive and knew the menu. Ill be coming back for some more fun in the sun here in Fort Pierce, FL and try some more burgers paired with their churro milk shakes in the near future. Definitely give this place a try!

Frequently Asked Questions About Island Burger and Shake