Customers praised the deep dish pizza as authentic and delicious, while opinions on the thin crust varied, with some finding it lacking.
Service Experience
Service received mixed reviews; some customers highlighted attentive and friendly staff, while others reported long wait times and poor communication.
Pricing Concerns
Many customers felt the prices were high for the quality of food, with some expressing dissatisfaction over perceived value.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's ambiance received positive feedback for being cozy and inviting, though some noted cleanliness issues and dated decor.
Customer Loyalty
Despite mixed experiences, several customers expressed a desire to return, particularly for the deep dish pizza and overall dining experience.
CB
Chris Badger
Nov 16, 2025
5.0
OMG, I can't wait to try the Deep dish pizza. Italian Beef is also excellent.
RR
Rick Rewerts
Nov 15, 2025
1.0
I paid over $40 for a deep-dish pizza and when I got it home, they had left off the meat. I called them and all that they would offer is $5 off of my next order. Don't waste your money on carryout from Baked!
BB
Bill Biz
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
I’m from the home of ‘real’ pizza, Chicago. Baked is easily one of the best pizza I’ve had in the 5 years we’ve been in Fort Myers. Great thin crust, sauce just sweet enough and a very good pepperoni. We wil eat here again.
JH
Jamie H
Nov 1, 2025
5.0
Tried many pizzas in SW FL, this is my favorite. No need to keep looking for the pizza ya miss back North- get that pizza right here at Baked 🍕 Staff outgoing too.
BS
Brian Simmons
Nov 1, 2025
3.0
So you wonder why 3 stars. Tired of restaurants screwing customers over. 3% service charge with debit cards, the restaurant is making money on the customer. If you do take out they charge $3. IDK, one server will say food costs the other will say paper cost. However, eating in they don’t charge for the box. Confused??? I am. Good pizza Chicago style is you have had them before. Owner is very confrontational along with his wife. I think they think they are Chicago mafia. Truly not Ft Myers types. The owner doesn’t even get out to meet his dime in customers. Doesn’t understand the hospitality business. Go to NY Pizza.
Where can I view the menu and place an order for Baked (Formerly Buddyz)?
You can view the menu and place an order online at https://chicagobakedpizzeria.com/menu.
What is the price range at Baked (Formerly Buddyz)?
The price range at Baked (Formerly Buddyz) is categorized as Two ($).
Can I get takeout from Baked (Formerly Buddyz)?
Yes, Baked (Formerly Buddyz) offers takeout services during their opening hours.
Is Baked (Formerly Buddyz) near any popular dessert spots?
Yes, Baked (Formerly Buddyz) is near Humble Donut Co. and Orange Leaf Frozen Yogurt, perfect spots to enjoy a dessert before or after your meal.
Are there any medical facilities close to Baked (Formerly Buddyz)?
Yes, nearby medical options include Rory Daniel Riverchase Dermatology, Riverchase Dermatology, and Joseph P. Santini PA-C, convenient if you are in the area for both health and dining needs.
What shopping centers are close to Baked (Formerly Buddyz)?
Baked (Formerly Buddyz) is located near The Forum shopping center, Ross Dress for Less, and Bed Bath & Beyond, so you can shop and dine conveniently in one trip.