I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill

4.3
1667 reviews
Get DirectionsCallWebsite

Business Details

532 Cagan Park Ave, Clermont, FL
34714, United States
(352) 432-3928
https://ilovenypizza4corners.com

About

Pizza Restaurant

Location

I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill
532 Cagan Park Ave, Clermont, FL
34714, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.3
1,667 reviews
5 stars
1,093
4 stars
257
3 stars
111
2 stars
76
1 star
130

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

Most customers praised the pizza as delicious, with many highlighting the garlic knots and other menu items as well.

Service

The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, welcoming, and attentive, particularly mentioning employees like Ellie and Eli.

Delivery Speed

Customers frequently noted that delivery was fast and food arrived hot, contributing to a positive experience.

Cleanliness

Some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, particularly with the restaurant's atmosphere and decor, suggesting room for improvement.

Value

While many found the food to be well-priced, a few customers felt that certain items were overpriced for the quality received.
  • BS
    Bob Sexton
    6 days ago
    2.0
    I rarely write negative reviews but I need to this time. We had a group of 5 and ordered 2 pizzas. The pizzas were good not great but we're passable. The service was really odd. The waiter was just kind of an odd guy. Not really bad but not great either. My big problem though was the bill. When we got our bill it had an 18 percent service charge already on the bill. And that's OK but I gave him my card and he returned with another receipt that had a space for a tip and suggested tip amounts showing what we should tip. If I hadn't looked closely at the first bill I would have left an additional 20 percent tip on top of the 18 percent they automatically figured in. I found this to be extremely deceitful and misleading. I might have gone back for the pizza sometime but not now because of the service and the misleading service charges.
  • LJ
    laquan james
    Nov 13, 2025
    5.0
    Elli customer service was amazing. She greeting us and gave us a awesome recommendation on food
  • KP
    Karen Pearson
    Nov 7, 2025
    5.0
    Staying at one of the campgrounds and decided to pizza. We ordered the extra large cheese and mushroom and onions, absolutely delicious would order again.
  • RB
    Rob Bradley
    Nov 3, 2025
    1.0
    After entering, we were instructed to sit anywhere, which of course is fine. I had entered to buy the happy hour deal, which is 2, 1 topping medium pizzas for $20. I get there and the sign at the restaurant say $25 instead of $20. That's fine, its still a good deal. We sit down and we go to order beer. The first one we order is out. The second one we order is out. This repeats 5 times. We say fine. We go to order the pizza. The waiter leaves and comes back and states that it is for take out only. At this point we got up and left. Will never go back
  • JF
    Josie Flores
    Oct 23, 2025
    5.0
    Ellie was so pleasant and welcoming and the food! Can’t go wrong with pizza and wings for dinner! Definitely recommend. And don’t forget your garlic knots. 😋
Read more reviews on Google

Frequently Asked Questions About I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill

What are the regular dining hours for I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill?

The restaurant is open from 10:00 AM to 10:00 PM Monday through Wednesday, and stays open until midnight Thursday to Sunday.

Does I Love NY Pizza Restaurant Bar & Grill offer delivery and in-store pickup?

Yes, the restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.