Papa's New York Diner

4.3
4376 reviews

About

Diner

Details

  • DeliveryAvailable
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Curbside pickupAvailable

Location

Papa's New York Diner
1764 Gulf to Bay Blvd, Clearwater, FL
33755, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.3
4,376 reviews
5 stars
2,760
4 stars
842
3 stars
350
2 stars
140
1 star
284

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Food Quality

The food is generally praised as delicious, with many customers highlighting specific dishes like burgers, pancakes, and desserts.

Service Experience

Customer service is inconsistent; while some reviews commend friendly and attentive staff, others report poor service and long wait times.

Atmosphere

The diner has a nostalgic, classic vibe that many customers appreciate, contributing to a welcoming dining experience.

24-Hour Availability

The diner’s 24-hour service is a significant draw for customers, especially those looking for late-night meals.

Cleanliness Issues

Some reviews mention cleanliness concerns, particularly in the bathrooms, which detracts from the overall experience.
  • RH
    Richard Housewright
    Dec 31, 2025
    1.0
    I usually order on my way home from work and when I get there its usually ready I might have to wait no more than 5 minutes. But, if I order when I get there and if I order breakfast why do I have to wait on my toast or biscuits so long? When my order is in the bag why should I wait so long on my biscuits? Shouldn't the order all come out together? Last night I just had my server refund my money. I'm very disappointed in the service there. It's uncall for. Especially when I've been coming in for the past three weeks every night getting my dinner. And here I'm sitting there watching all this other food come out of the window and I'm just waiting on two biscuits?
  • SE
    Sierra E
    Dec 28, 2025
    5.0
    Holy hell this place is a gem, for starters it is insanely cool, my jaw was on the floor. The staff were incredible, we dined in pretty late last night (which this place is open for dine-in 24hrs you can never find that anymore) and immediately felt so welcomed. Our server Omayra was amazing, her personality put the experience over the top and she was so incredible and helpful. I haven’t even gotten started on the food. Literally to die for, I cannot recommend this place enough. Never change a thing.
  • LV
    Liana Velazquez
    Dec 27, 2025
    5.0
    This was our first time here and Isabel our waitress was very attempted, and she made my stepson’s night by giving him positive affirmations on his cups and he loved it. The food was very fresh and hearty. We’ll be back again! Customer service was amazing and it made it worth coming out for dinner.
  • MH
    Monica Hinds
    Dec 25, 2025
    2.0
    Sunday crew doesn't seem to want to wait on my family especially Dave. Guess he can pick who he wants to wait on even if you sit in his section. We leave approximately 30 percent tip each time. Night shift is great. Guess I will only be taking my family at night. Hate it because we like to have dinner and not breakfast all the time.
  • IS
    Iain Strait
    Dec 23, 2025
    5.0
    Papa's is a clearwater classic. The layout of the restaurant resembles that of what you'd picture for a retro dinner, black and white flooring, red booths, and a modern jukebox. The menu is large, with many excellent selections. My fiancé rare steak was cooked perfect, and my go-to item is the prime rib burger. This is one of the few restaurants in Pinellas that still operate 24 hours. So for all your night shift workers, you are in luck!

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa's New York Diner

What are the operating hours of Papa's New York Diner?

Papa's New York Diner is open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Does Papa's New York Diner offer delivery and pickup services?

Yes, Papa's New York Diner offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.