Papa's New York Diner

Reviews

• SH

  Spencer Hayes

  2 days ago
  5.0
  I love this place. It’s so warm and welcoming. The food is fantastic and reasonably priced. The staff is friendly. It has a traditional diner vibe but still manages to stay contemporary and relevant. It’s a very casual and go with the flow sort of venue. It’s my favorite place to go late night just cause I feel at home there. I always want to try something new but can’t stop ordering Papa’s omelette!
• AY

  Ashleigh Young

  2 days ago
  2.0
  They changed my favorite French fries to these crappy crinkle cut ones. I called to ask if it was permanent and they PROMISED it was temporary. Here i am a month later with their new crappy fries crying into my ketchup. Please bring my fries back 🙏
• AS

  Alissa Schlafley

  Feb 21, 2026
  1.0
  Spent $50 on 2 meals I Ordered chicken and waffles and I received a styrofoam container with a waffle and And another containing fried bone in chicken breasts and a single old fry. I called up and the lady lied to me saying quote on quote “we’ve been serving it as bone in chicken breasts for a while now” haha she hung up so quick and then I looked on the recent reviews and photos and saw that was in fact a lie . So I assume the chicken tenders and fries also come as bone in chicken breasts now right? The fact that a person that’s working for a company can’t be honest about the simplest things is beyond me. I can’t be upset if you’re honest, but I can be beyond upset when I find out you are straight up lying to me as if I’m some fool. Photos what I received in the styrofoam and the right photo is another customers review from a month ago .
• SN

  Sylvia Nagy

  Feb 17, 2026
  5.0
  A real American diner experience. Only come if you would like to reminisce the old days and then you will enjoy every minute of it. Old-fashioner decor and menu, fast and friendly service.
• RW

  Rashiadah Weaver

  Feb 5, 2026
  4.0
  Great customer service. Food was good just needed a little more seasoning. The staff was so friendly and professional. Our party arrived late night and we left full! When one of our party wasn't satisfied with there order , They were given something else no questions asked. Top notch service. Great atmosphere